I have a mystery with my insoles. Hoping someone here might have some ideas about it.
For about 5 years, I've gotten custom insoles from a local running store. I have high arches, a high instep, and wide feet. About a month ago, I needed a new pair of custom insoles. The new ones were from the same store, the same type, the same size as the ones I had been wearing. I put them in my running shoes (not new shoes) and did two runs in them two days in a row totaling over 15 miles.
The next day when I put on my shoes (with the new insoles) for a run, the insoles felt wrong. It felt like the arches were in the wrong place. I hadn't taken the insoles out since the previous two runs. When they felt wrong, I took them in and out a few times to make sure they were properly seated. They still felt wrong. I convinced myself it was all in my head. I ran an easy 5 miles. The next day, the arches of my feet felt all bruised up, like I'd worn insoles with the arches in the wrong place, or maybe arches that were too high!
The next run, I went back to the old insoles. Then I tried the new ones again on the run after that. They still felt wrong. This was just a couple of weeks before my Ragnar, so I didn't want to beat up my feet too much. I stuck with the old insoles through Ragnar.
After Ragnar, I got some new running shoes. I'd had a week off from running. I put the new insoles in the new shoes and ran 4.5 easy miles. The insoles felt fine. No problems afterward.
That was yesterday. Tonight I put on the same new shoes and the new insoles and the insoles felt wrong. Again, I took them in and out a bunch. I sort of convinced myself that they felt "better" after doing this and ran 4 miles. But now several hours after, I can tell my feet feel bruised again.
I can't figure out what is going on. Why do the insoles feel OK sometimes and not others? I have never had this happen, despite using the same type of insoles for years. They are moderately expensive, so I don't want to just chuck them. Also, if I got a another new pair, how do I know the same thing won't happen?
Any ideas?