I've yet to see the appeal of the paid FP. We stay CL no matter if it's a short trip or a long one. As long as the CL FP are unmodifiable then we'll never do them. Plus, we always get on all the rides we want with the 3 regular and same day FP.
The paid FPs work really well for us and make it possible to hit the tier 1 rides in the same day. Our trips are usually short so we try to pack it all in!
On day 1 (a busy Saturday in April), we will start our day in AK and then go to Epcot. With the paid FPs, we will get a morning FOP, test track and soarin. FOP would prob be unavailable at 60 days and we wouldn’t be able to get a Navi FP as well. Of course, we probably couldn’t get the Epcot FPs for those tier 1 rides. For our 4th, 5th reg FPs, we’ll try for dinosaur while in AK and then all of the other rides while at Epcot.
The next day we’re going to HS early to try to get a boarding group. (Ugh! Wish there was a better system). If we don’t get the paid FPs, we can only get 1 tier 1 FP at HS and SDD will likely be unavailable at 60 days... and the park will prob be very crowded in the morning - long lines for everything! With the paid FPs, we can get 4 tier 1 rides (SDD, RnR, Tower, TSM) lined up in the morning. Sounds like SR and the new Mickey ride won’t have FPs so we will already have to wait in long lines for them...
Our last day is our check out day and my daughters bday so we’ll have breakfast and head out slowly so won’t get to Mk til 11. It’ll be great to have 6 headliners lined up for the day for her. We will book the 1st 3 as our reg FPs so we can work on 4th and 5th FPs. Hopefully no waiting in any lines that day. We head to the airport that evening.
We’re coming from NJ for 3 days so we want to make sure we’re able to get on the main rides and fit everything in with our favorite ADRs and make the best use of our time. If we were staying for a week, we prob wouldn’t get the paid FPs as we’d have time to get on everything on have 60+7 days to work with when booking the reg FPs.
Honestly, I do it for my 3 kids. I don’t want them to be disappointed. I personally just like being at Disney and don’t care much about going on rides.
Also, just FYI, you can modify your paid FPs by calling the SS line. Not ideal and availability late in the game will be limited...