DH and I really like Tony's and we go there pretty much every trip. I know it gets a lot of haters, but I like the décor, and while it is not the greatest Italian food ever, it's always been tasty. I get the shrimp scampi and DH gets a short rib dish, though, and I've heard most people who don't like it get the red-sauce dishes, so maybe it depends on what you order.
We've been to Skippers a couple of times and I have to say I'm a bit surprised by all the love here. It was kind of "meh" for us--reminded me a lot of P.F. Changs. Then again, my parents love P.F. Chang's, so maybe DH and I are just oddballs.