CARNIVAL VS DCL: The discussion and comparison thread!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Disney Cruise Line/Dream: 2900$ For Nassau & Castaway Cay
Royal Carribean/Mariner: 1050$ For Nassau & CocoCay (re-imagined)
Carnival/Liberty: 830$ For Nassau & Half Moon Cay
:scared1: Holy smokes is that a difference! I get brand loyalty to Disney but sheesh!

Where did you guys get your carnival cruise countdown? Is it an app?
Have 150 days to my very first cruise! Be gentle with the newbie:laughing:
 
DH and I had a conversation last night regarding the price of cruising. Unless there is a new cruiseship that I'd be dying to try in the future, we really don't see ourselves coming back to DCL unless they reduce their prices dramatically and offer a better value for us than other cruise lines.

We don't blame DCL for this one. We blame the other cruise lines for being so affordable and excellent. :P

I'm grateful that the money we are saving right now on vacations will most likely permit to afford a trip with my friends, when I usually wouldn't have the money to do so (most of my budget going for family vacations).
 
There is a Carnival Hub App, you should get it before you get on a ship :) It is how you can check your account on the trip, among other things (buy pictures, check the daily schedule). Also allows you get a cool count down timer pre-cruise.
 
:scared1: Holy smokes is that a difference! I get brand loyalty to Disney but sheesh!

Where did you guys get your carnival cruise countdown? Is it an app?
Have 150 days to my very first cruise! Be gentle with the newbie:laughing:

Yes, the price difference is shocking. I couldn't believe my eyes either. My first DCL cruise was in 2015, we paid 600$/pp for a 3 nights in the Bahamas and now it seems to be between 700 and 850$/pp... Which is a lot of money for such a short cruise.

There's an app if you want a countdown on your phone and computers (Carnival Hub) but if you are talking about my tickers, you can make your own here and you just have to include it in your signature... http://distickers.com/ticker/
 


Thanks all-I got the Carnival app! will have DH get it too as it looks like it is useful onboard!

I believe you can pay $5 each and use it to communicate on the ship. My son is too young for his own phone so I didn't try that out but it sounds great if you both have phones.
 


Been pricing out short 4 nights Bahamas cruise for my girls trip in December 2020. I checked December 2018 and 2019 to get an idea...

For 3 Adults in an inside cabin:

Disney Cruise Line/Dream: 2900$ For Nassau & Castaway Cay
Royal Carribean/Mariner: 1050$ For Nassau & CocoCay (re-imagined)
Carnival/Liberty: 830$ For Nassau & Half Moon Cay

Everyone is in disbelief regarding the DCL prices vs the others.

One of them has already crossed DCL off the list and says she doesn't know if she will be able to afford the trip if the other two pick DCL. I can afford any of those cruises but I see her point and value her presence more than Mickey's.

WOW, at those prices you could do three cruises for the price of one Disney!
 
Yep. Two RCCL and three Carnival!
WOW, at those prices you could do three cruises for the price of one Disney!
We went from B2B's with DCL (14 days) to B2B's on RCCL. I almost fell over when I realized what I was saving. I was pretty much getting the 2 RCCL for the cost of 1 DCL plus saving the 35% exchange rate. Win win!
I think we will be back on DCL one more time in three years, once the grandson turns 5. Disney is a right of passage for my wee one's. Once they hit 5 they get to meet the mouse in one way or another. With the parks being so crowded now we thought DCL may be the way to go for this one.
 
We went from B2B's with DCL (14 days) to B2B's on RCCL. I almost fell over when I realized what I was saving. I was pretty much getting the 2 RCCL for the cost of 1 DCL plus saving the 35% exchange rate. Win win!
I think we will be back on DCL one more time in three years, once the grandson turns 5. Disney is a right of passage for my wee one's. Once they hit 5 they get to meet the mouse in one way or another. With the parks being so crowded now we thought DCL may be the way to go for this one.

My friend has a daughter who works at WDW. She wants to take 2 of her grandchildren on a Disney Cruise, but could only afford the 3-night even WITH her daughter's discount!
 
I believe you can pay $5 each and use it to communicate on the ship. My son is too young for his own phone so I didn't try that out but it sounds great if you both have phones.
Yes, it’s $5 per device for the entire cruise and just an FYI, if you have an old smart phone that you no longer use but still is capable of WiFi, you can let your son use that on board to text with you. You can also use an iPod Touch.
 
DH and I had a conversation last night regarding the price of cruising. Unless there is a new cruiseship that I'd be dying to try in the future, we really don't see ourselves coming back to DCL unless they reduce their prices dramatically and offer a better value for us than other cruise lines.

We don't blame DCL for this one. We blame the other cruise lines for being so affordable and excellent. :P

I'm grateful that the money we are saving right now on vacations will most likely permit to afford a trip with my friends, when I usually wouldn't have the money to do so (most of my budget going for family vacations).
After our Alaska cruise in June on the Wonder I know we won’t be on another Disney ship until at least 2021 when the new one comes out. Even my 16 year old daughter who was the biggest DCL cheerleader in the family only wants the Carnival ships until the Disney ship sets sail.
 
After our Alaska cruise in June on the Wonder I know we won’t be on another Disney ship until at least 2021 when the new one comes out. Even my 16 year old daughter who was the biggest DCL cheerleader in the family only wants the Carnival ships until the Disney ship sets sail.

I hope you'll do a trip report from your trip to Alaska with a lot of pictures.

I've been dying to cruise Alaska but when there are no beaches, my husband is not interested. My Alaska 40th birthday cruise project for 2019 turned into Amber Cove-Grand Turk because of that. :/ Not that I don't want to go to Amber Cove or Grand Turk but it wasn't exactly what I was hoping for.
 
I booked the Carnival Horizon for our 2019 cruise. I think the July 3 night on the Fantasy will be our last DCL for a while; at least it's my grand slam. I am getting close to retirement and can't justify the extra cost when it is just DH and I.
 
Communication posted on John Heald's page on Facebook...


CARNIVAL CRUISE LINE TO OFFER THREE EXCITING LONGER LENGTH CARNIVAL JOURNEYS SAILINGS IN 2019, INCLUDING 24-DAY TRANS-PACIFIC CROSSING, 13-DAY PANAMA CANAL TRANSIT AND 14-DAY HAWAII CRUISE

Carnival Miracle to Also Operate Series of Seven-Day Mexican Riviera Cruises from Long Beach Beginning Next Year

MIAMI (May 15, 2018) – As Carnival Cruise Line continues to expand its itinerary offerings, the company today announced that it will offer three special longer length Carnival Journeys cruises in 2019.
The voyages include a unique 24-day trans-Pacific crossing aboard Carnival Splendor from Long Beach to Singapore, as well as two voyages aboard Carnival Miracle – a 13-day Panama Canal transit from Tampa to Long Beach and a 14-day Hawaii cruise round-trip from Long Beach.

The 24-day voyage is the longest single departure in Carnival Cruise Line’s history and marks the first time that the line will visit Guam, Vietnam and Malaysia on a North American departure.
In addition to visiting some of the world’s most beautiful destinations, guests sailing on Carnival Journeys cruises enjoy unique on-board activities during which they can sample local cuisine and enjoy entertainment and cultural opportunities within the various ports of call. Activities focusing on topics such as photography, cooking, arts and crafts and celestial navigation, along with a 1980s-themed “Throwback Sea Day,” are also offered.
“We’re delighted to expand upon our itinerary choices with these three exciting Carnival Journeys, including an unforgettable 24-day voyage trans-Pacific transit featuring our first-ever calls to spectacular ports in the Far East,” said Christine Duffy, president of Carnival Cruise Line.

24-Day Transpacific Crossing on Carnival Splendor
The 3,012-passenger Carnival Splendor will operate an unprecedented 24-day trans-Pacific crossing that will depart Long Beach, Calif., on Oct. 5 and arrive in Singapore Oct. 30, 2019.
The voyage will feature extended port calls at Maui and Honolulu, Hawaii, before crossing the International Date Line, then visit Guam, and Kota Kinabalu, Malaysia and Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam – the first time the line has visited these destinations on a ship departing from North America. On this fantastic seagoing adventure guests can visit ancient temples and other centuries-old landmarks and attractions and immerse themselves in Far East culture.
The 24-day voyage will also offer a traditional ceremony held when mariners cross the International Date Line which essentially adds an extra day to the cruise.

13-day Panama Canal, 14-Day Hawaii Carnival Journeys Cruises

Carnival Miracle will operate a 13-day Carnival Journeys Panama Canal transit that will depart Tampa Sept. 29 and arrive in Long Beach Oct. 12, 2019, positioning the vessel for a series of seven- and 14-day cruises from that port.

The 13-day cruise will include an overnight stay in Cartagena, Colombia; prior to the Panama Canal transit followed by calls at Puerto Quetzal, Guatemala; and Cabo San Lucas, Mexico, all home to magnificent architecture and unforgettable shopping, dining and cultural experiences.
Carnival Miracle will also operate a 14-day Carnival Journeys cruise to Hawaii round-trip from Long Beach Oct. 19 to Nov. 2, 2019, featuring stops at four breathtaking destinations within the Aloha State – Maui, Honolulu, Kona and Hilo – along with a call at Ensenada, Mexico. On this cruise, guests can enjoy world-class beaches, savor local cuisine, explore the lush Hawaiian countryside and get an “up close and personal look” at colorful Polynesian culture.


The ship will also offer a series of seven-day Mexican Riviera cruises from Long Beach beginning Oct. 12, 2019. The week-long voyages visit Puerto Vallarta, Mazatlan and Cabo San Lucas, all home to gorgeous white-sand beaches, excellent snorkeling and a variety of water sports.

Please share this would you.

Cheers
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

GET A DISNEY VACATION QUOTE

Dreams Unlimited Travel is committed to providing you with the very best vacation planning experience possible. Our Vacation Planners are experts and will share their honest advice to help you have a magical vacation.

Let us help you with your next Disney Vacation!


GET UP TO A $1000 SHIPBOARD CREDIT AND AN EXCLUSIVE GIFT!

If you make your Disney Cruise Line reservation with Dreams Unlimited Travel you’ll receive these incredible shipboard credits to spend on your cruise!















facebook twitter
Top