we have used it the last 2 trips and LOVE it!!!!!!!!! it is just my wife and i so it really works out well for us. we are both people who skip breakfast everyday. we use the features for our meals for the entire stay!! last year we went to the living seas to eat, when the waitress found out we had the plan she said, "oh go with the surf and turf, its 58$ apiece but for you it is already paid for!" so we did (total $176, for LUNCH!!) when else in our lives are two teachers going to be able to do that!!!!! the tips earlier were great. i also highly recommend disney quest. there is a whole floor of nothing but video games from the 80's (they are all free!) plus stuff like vr rides, new video games, the roller coaster simulator. it is a great place to spend an afternoon (especially on a hot or rainy day). we like the plan because we eat at a lot of places we never would without it. plus with all you can eat we really only need the two meals a day. we dont use our wishes on counter service. instead we usually pick one day, eat a counter lunch, and you those to get a souvenier or something, (last year tried a watermouse, but not worth it. too underpowered for someone like me, 250lbs, just kind of sputtered along). i have noticed this year they added preferred seating at the fireworks. i am anxious to see how this works.
overall i recommend it, but only if you are going to take advantage of it and eat some really good food.
mikewdw