We prefer to fly out of our local Long Island airport, which like you allows us two options - Southwest and Frontier. Since Frontier came to Long Island last October, we have used them almost exclusively - we were frequent fliers on Southwest up until that point. The Frontier prices (even accounting for paying for everything a la carte) are way below SW prices - it is rare for us to even check a bag, let alone 2 each, somewhat negating the benefit of SW not charging for bags.
For the most part all of our flights have been uneventful. We have flown Frontier to Orlando, Fort Myers, West Palm Beach, Minneapolis, Chicago and Myrtle Beach. There have been delays - primarily because of weather. We easily used their emergency illness policy in November when our dd had a medical emergency (and she was not even flying with us, and she was over 21).
This past Saturday - on my 30th leg on Frontier - was the first major issue i have had with the airline.
Flight was scheduled to depart at 12:25 pm.
Around 10:15 am they posted a delay of 30 minutes.
Around 11:30, the departure time was changed to 2:30 pm.
At 11:50, I received an email that a meal voucher was available for pickup at the gate.
I was in the lounge, so elected to just spend my time there instead of going to the gate to collect it.
At 1:50, departure time was still posted as 2:30. I made my way to the gate.
Inquired and my meal voucher was still available - it was $10. They admitted that they would not even know what time the flight would be leaving until 2:30 pm.
Plane boarded at 3:30, left at 4:00 pm.
Communication could have been better.
Turns out the first delay was because of air control - Trump was visiting Long Island, which caused a stop on most flights in the tri-state area. Then a flight from somewhere else landed with a mechanical problem. After a while, they made the decision to take 'our' plane that was sitting at the gate unused and use it for the next flight that was supposed to use the plane with the problem. They were working on the plane for our flight. However, that plane was much smaller than our original. They 'found' another large plane for us eventually.
Landed 3 hours late. 15 minutes after landing, I received an email from Frontier with an unsolicited $50 voucher.
Had the flight been cancelled - the options would have been
- to re-book on the next available Frontier flight - which would have been Wednesday for the majority of passengers. Although, there were flights daily from MCO to ISP - they were primarily sold out until Wednesday. Also, would have received a $400 voucher
- to re-book on another airline and get up to $400 refunded towards the fare on that airline. The fare for the Southwest flight leaving later that evening was $509 - a family did opt to do that around 3:00 pm, and had to do so out of their own pocket and would receive no compensation from Frontier since it was 'voluntary'. As it turns out, they wound up back on the Frontier flight because the SW flight was delayed and would not have left until hours after our re-scheduled flight.
I have heard and seen many horror stories about Frontier, but my personal experience has not had many hurdles. I do seem to notice that there are some airports that see way more problems with Frontier than others.