I dont even mind if they keep the same PIF date but they need to change the cancellation penalties and the related timelines for when you start losing money. Many people, including myself, will not want to feel the need to start calculating risk, odds, and commitment 4 months before sailing. If I’m forced to make a decision that far in advance, the only one I could choose is to cancel and get our deposit refunded.
This would especially hit them hard for port-intensive cruises that take a great deal of planning in advance such as Europe and Alaska.
For a 3-4 nighter to Bahamas, I can pack some shorts, tops and bathing suit & flip flops in an hour and be ready to roll. Been there done that and still had a great time. Booked on a Tuesday night, flew Thursday, sailed Friday.