Has anyone used a magic band puck watch slider?

[Queen of the WDW Scene]

I've had a fitbit for the past few trips and I'm not one to even wear it all day at home let alone all day at the parks plus wearing a magic band on the other wrist so I've been trying to figure out how to combine them on to one wrist.
I just came across and Etsy shop that makes a puck holder that slides onto a watch or fitness tracker.
Just wondering if anyone has used something like that and if they found any pros or cons of it.
Like did it slide around a lot? was it uncomfortable? is it the best thing since sliced bread? lol.

 

[gap2368]

I have seen people use this and they liked it.

 

[SSRJen]

I bought one and have used it for five trips. It is great and very comfortable for me. The one I have is pretty hard to get on the apple watch, but it also stays in place well.

 

[gatorlisa]

I have had two. Both 3D printed. One was very rigid, difficult to get onto the type of Apple watch band I use, and actually cracked. The other is made of a more flexible material, so can bend/squeeze/stretch it just a little bit to get it onto watch bands, yet still holds the puck very securely. I love this one. Wore it for a total of 12 park days in September. I loved not having to wear the MagicBand, yet still have the puck on my wrist. It was very comfortable and I hardly noticed the extra bulk on my watch band. I got it from Etsy.

 

[SaintsManiac]

I have this one and I love it.

https://www.etsy.com/listing/532668...band-2-puck-keeper?ref=shop_home_feat_1&bes=1

It does not move at all.

 

[Giz1026]

https://www.etsy.com/listing/620806573/magic-band-2-flexible-puck-holder-watch

I used this one for a 10 day trip with my Fossil smart watch. Loved that I didn't have to wear an extra band. The only complaint I had is I placed the holder on the inside strap of my wrist. When I would scan it my watch face would get bumped against the readers and I was concerned with my watch face getting scratched up. Lucky for me I didnt have any scratches at the end of the trip but I was very cognizant of placing the face against the sensors once I noticed the possibility of scratching it. The outer strap of my watch has too large of a buckle to allow the holder to slide on that side so I will be ordering another style.

 

[TheMick424]

Any one with recent recommendations for this type of product? I’ve searched on Etsy but am having a hard time determining which is the best option - both secure and comfortable. Any suggestions?

 

[gatorlisa]

I have pretty much abandoned wearing an actual MagicBand in favor of a puck holder for my watch. I have several, all from the same Etsy shop. Love them. They are made of a flexible plastic, which makes getting them on and off watch bands much easier. They are from the shop Luke3DP.

 

[ArmchairDetective]

If you have access to a 3D printer (local library, friend, etc), you can print your own! I just printed several on my own printer for our upcoming trip. https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:3586302