nedleycan-
All the Palo reservations can be made in Rockin' Bar D after boarding. When I made reservations for the 2/22 Magic, there was one table for dinner reservations, and a second table for brunch/tea reservations. I was fortunate to arrive before lines had formed, so I was able to walk up to each table, but I would assume that eventually two lines formed. It may be worth having two people there, one for each line.
I was successful in making reservations for tea, however! Here was my game plan: arrived at the port around 10:30, in the boarding line by 11:00 or so, boarded around 12:15 and went directly to Rockin' Bar D for Palo ressies. We basically had our choice of times/days for all three meals. We then went to the spa (again, had our choice of times), hit the stateroom to drop off our bags, and finally had lunch! It worked out perfectly - but since we don't have children, we didn't have to add Flounders into the mix.
All of the meals we had in Palo were fabulous, but brunch was definitely my favorite - so much variety, wonderful shrimp and crab (and hummus and cheese and smoked salmon...), a fantastic mushroom pizza, and of course the lovely view of the ocean. We hardly had room for dessert - so Dalibor packed up a fruit pizza for us to take to our room! Be sure to try a Bellini as well - yum!
April