Spidey,
I want to tell you to do HRH, but I would feel horrible if you had a bad experience! I really liked the HRH, but as you know, we are going to RPR in November and I am not worried at all that I won't like it as much as HRH. So, maybe that tells you something.
If you want to try something new, HRH is really cool. The memorabilia (sp) is so cool to look at, and the pool and rooms were great. The exception would be a deluxe - I wouldn't get one personally. The one we had was worn, stained carpet, and had those horrible green bedspreads, and I have heard others same similiar things about deluxes.
As for club level, I would do it again going with my two kids, but wouldn't do it for just us as a couple or if I had kids who ate like birds. My 8 year old eats like nobody business, and paying 221 for club level was a much bigger savings then buying breakfast and dinner snacks every day.
If you or your family were very, very happy with RPR and you think you would be thinking about RPR during your HRH stay, then stay there again. You could pool hop to HRH and eat at the restaurants and make a decision to stay next time. If you wait until November to decide, I will have stayed at both and can give you my opinion then