RCCL Star vs MSC Yacht Club

John VN

N.Y. STYLE CHEESECAKE RULES!!!
Joined
Aug 2, 2003
Oasis Sky in Crown Loft was great and in DW and My opnion's MUCH better than 1BR DCL Concierge. Have 2 MCS Yacht Club on Seaside and it reads like RCCL Star so hoping for anybody having an actual cruising comparison?

TIA
 
The standard msc deluxe yacht club rooms will be much smaller than the the sky loft on Oasis. You do not get free specialty restaurants but have to pay for them on MSC YC. Will have to purchase internet on MSC. Love the YC pool deck with hot tubs and lounge on 18. Have to check out the spa facilities. Hydrotherapy pool, salt room, scented shower, geyser room beats anything royal has. The top sail lounge is nice to pass the day away reading and the service is great. I enjoyed both but the value of MSC YC cannot be beat. We got to cruise 2 weeks on MSC seaside for about the same as what royal wanted for one week in a crown loft during the same time in July. Actually is was more like 75% of what royal was charging 1 week in a CLS.
 
The standard msc deluxe yacht club rooms will be much smaller than the the sky loft on Oasis. You do not get free specialty restaurants but have to pay for them on MSC YC. Will have to purchase internet on MSC. Love the YC pool deck with hot tubs and lounge on 18. Have to check out the spa facilities. Hydrotherapy pool, salt room, scented shower, geyser room beats anything royal has. The top sail lounge is nice to pass the day away reading and the service is great. I enjoyed both but the value of MSC YC cannot be beat. We got to cruise 2 weeks on MSC seaside for about the same as what royal wanted for one week in a crown loft during the same time in July. Actually is was more like 75% of what royal was charging 1 week in a CLS.

Thanks for your experience. For sure the YC Suite is smaller than the CL and we're OK with that but as you mentioned the value compared to say a Grand Suite on Oasis or the regular Concierge on the Dream is so much greater. Since we aren't foodies the fact that there's no Specialty Dining privileges doesn't bother us and with the money saved the internet cost is minimal. With the 10% off they just ran plus our 5% matching, next year's cruise is even more of a value.
 

GET A DISNEY VACATION QUOTE

Dreams Unlimited Travel is committed to providing you with the very best vacation planning experience possible. Our Vacation Planners are experts and will share their honest advice to help you have a magical vacation.

Let us help you with your next Disney Vacation!





Top