Because sometimes I mis-read the OP, or sometimes I'm tired or distracted from chasing my 3 kids around or I don't always see the necessity in every last detail, or sometimes I want to be brief, or sometimes I just don't see every detail as relevant at the time. Sometimes 30 other people have said "yes! I did that! or "no, they never allowed this once in the 30 days I was there!" and I just don't feel like it's necessary to join the chorus to prove a point. Sometimes, until I look at photos or notes or whatever I bother with during the trip, I just plain don't remember. Would you like me to get into more details concerning my memory here, or do you feel you've embarrassed me enough for one day?
But, since you felt the need to go through 600 plus posts over five or so months to essentially call me a liar (or whatever it is you're really attempting at doing here because if that wasn't it, then a personal message or a question rather than a statement would have been more appropriate here), I feel it necessary to I have absolutely nothing invested in how anyone chooses to book FP and I don't have a crystal ball telling me which day or attraction the "half and half game" is going to work on, so anyone can book as they choose and at their own risk. If anyone is still able to book this way and not having any issues, great.
No, my September trip isn't relevant except to say that after the inconsistency of the August trip I realized that my choices are to either book FP for everyone, or risk not going on something using FP in conjunction with RS.
If I am mis-reading you here then I sincerely apologize, but honestly I can't imagine doing to someone what you've done here.