As a SSR owner, I was thrilled to see that Zagat's rated SSR as having the best and nicest rooms in all of WDW. They gfave SSR a 25 out of 28 for quality of rooms. I didn't see the other DVC ratings, but the critique did say that SSR has the nicest rooms so that made me happy as I have yet to stay at SSR. We just bought into DVC and we're going in January for our first trip home.