• Controversial Topics
    Several months ago, I added a private sub-forum to allow members to discuss these topics without fear of infractions or banning. It's opt-in, opt-out. Corey Click Here

Disney parks costs, crowds, and categorizations

Agree.
I've always found family vacations important and thus that is something I prioritize in the family budget (time and money). I find it shocking when families say they can't afford to go on them. Every family's situation is different, but I still find a Disney vacation affordable. Going big or going every year (or both)? A luxury. Going once in a blue moon .. still quite affordable when you compare it to things like:

Cancel cable for a year and you can have a decent, yet short, Disney Vacation.
Abstain from the member of your family from getting iPhone 8 for a year or two and the money you save (technology is the most expensive when it first comes out) could be used to get a few nights at Disney Resort.

Yeah, not really...$1K gets you very little for families bigger than 2 (since that's what canceling cable without losing internet and getting the new Iphone costs) - I mean, with 4 folks, you have 2 day passes and 1 hotel night...6 folks, you pretty much have single day tickets and a 1 night hotel stay...and in both cases, you still have no food and no way to get there...
 
Neither...

It was designed as a stable platform to promote their product to the largest swath of economic earners: the American middle class. Those that earn between the 25th and 75th percentile of the econmic earnings pattern.

Disney was never "cheap" nor made apologies about that...but it could be "affordable" for most...the current pricing strategy is on an arc that is outrunning average earnings.

That's fine...but they want 75 mil plus in Orlando every year and the pricing will make that impossible. Disney is currently deluded into what people's direct deposits say...or to be more specifics: how little they've grown.

Agreed - $2100 will get a family of 4 (2 under 12) on the Anthem of the Seas from NJ during Jersey Week 2018, all tips and ship costs included. That's all food, "in park" entertainment, and hotel for a week for what that same family might get just 7 day tickets and a day or two of a value hotel for a week in Orlando at the exact same time...
 
Agreed - $2100 will get a family of 4 (2 under 12) on the Anthem of the Seas from NJ during Jersey Week 2018, all tips and ship costs included. That's all food, "in park" entertainment, and hotel for a week for what that same family might get just 7 day tickets and a day or two of a value hotel for a week in Orlando at the exact same time...

very true ... and so you have to think, what am I getting for that "extra" money I need to spend at Disney. And is why more than the cost of things I think Disney needs to focus on the quality of their product - and when you see things like full garbage cans, attractions that need maintenance, cutting back on the length of CM training, etc. I think that is more detrimental in the long run than raising prices a bit

I know when I was a kid and we would travel my mother would always comment on how clean the parks were and that it made it more inviting for her, etc. - that is what she remembered, not the cost of anything, but the upkeep, etc.
 
Agree.
I've always found family vacations important and thus that is something I prioritize in the family budget (time and money). I find it shocking when families say they can't afford to go on them. Every family's situation is different, but I still find a Disney vacation affordable. Going big or going every year (or both)? A luxury. Going once in a blue moon .. still quite affordable when you compare it to things like:

Cancel cable for a year and you can have a decent, yet short, Disney Vacation.
Abstain from the member of your family from getting iPhone 8 for a year or two and the money you save (technology is the most expensive when it first comes out) could be used to get a few nights at Disney Resort.

And you clearly have a much bigger budget than most families, and obviously have a distorted view of what most people live on. Not sure what you're paying for cable, but we pay $80/mth. $960. That doesn't even buy a family of 4 tickets to Disney World, let alone meals, lodging and travel. For that matter, that doesn't even get you you a 3 or 4 night stay at a "cheap" hotel, with travel, lodging, meals and perhaps theme park tickets to a small local park.

And, while it may be hard to believe, many, if not, most families, actually don't have iPhone 8s, or iPhones of any kind, and don't have big $150-200/mth cell phone packages. That just is not the reality for most families.
 


And you clearly have a much bigger budget than most families, and obviously have a distorted view of what most people live on. Not sure what you're paying for cable, but we pay $80/mth. $960. That doesn't even buy a family of 4 tickets to Disney World, let alone meals, lodging and travel. For that matter, that doesn't even get you you a 3 or 4 night stay at a "cheap" hotel, with travel, lodging, meals and perhaps theme park tickets to a small local park.

And, while it may be hard to believe, many, if not, most families, actually don't have iPhone 8s, or iPhones of any kind, and don't have big $150-200/mth cell phone packages. That just is not the reality for most families.

I admit - no one in my family has a cell phone we pay for...our only cell is my spouse's work phone (which is paid for by his work)...we get along just fine without the bill, but it's not saving us an Orlando vacation every year...
 
very true ... and so you have to think, what am I getting for that "extra" money I need to spend at Disney. And is why more than the cost of things I think Disney needs to focus on the quality of their product - and when you see things like full garbage cans, attractions that need maintenance, cutting back on the length of CM training, etc. I think that is more detrimental in the long run than raising prices a bit

I know when I was a kid and we would travel my mother would always comment on how clean the parks were and that it made it more inviting for her, etc. - that is what she remembered, not the cost of anything, but the upkeep, etc.

Great point.

If they want to be the best, they can't and shouldn't do things like they are doing in regards to labor. For example, running rides at half capacity, letting waits get to 45 mins for no reason other than to save the $8/hr employees.

Give the people what you charge them for.

I think someone on these boards, I'm picturing a viking, has long railed against paying more for less. It's a valid point.
 
I don't know if anyone listens to the Mickey Miles and More Podcast but they had Len Testa on their past three episodes. They have been discussing Disney pricing structures from 1999 to today. They have also brought into account the household incomes, average number of vacation days, and how Disney classes their vacationers. It is a really interesting discussion and something I think goes unnoticed at times.

Finally got through all of these- interesting stuff! Thank you for sharing.

I know the conversation on here has kind of gone all over the place since post one, but oh well!

This was really reaffirming to listen to in the sense that it made me feel less crazy since I've been spending time on these boards. I truly think that there are a lot of users who are disconnected from what the "average" and "majority" household in America is- how much they make, how they are able to spend. It was SO REFRESHING to hear Len share the actual data that I have been trying to reconcile with what I read on here for some time now. Even more so to hear the Disney breakout of its audience. I want to listen to that again so I can capture it- can't seem to find that list online.

Their conversation about budget- to hear them fall silent and just kind of "wow" at the figures... YES! We need more of that. I also bet Manhattan steak tastes better than Disney steak.

My parents managed to take us twice as kids, and I do not think that is the norm. Both times we stayed offsite for free at a friend's condo in Daytona Beach. We brought food- although I do vaguely remember eating in Italy of Epcot and my parents being nervous about the cost. The first visit was free or heavily discounted as that friend's nanny was employed with WDW and got us in. The second visit was right after 9/11. My dad was deployed for about a year, and we went shortly after he got back when they were running some crazy promotion for the military. On that visit I was a teen-I think it was about 2003? I truly remember little of that trip as well. I know we visited one park per day. I know AK was hot. I know that I was not a fan of that one hour drive and walk around a park all day vacation. So yeah, even when your parents manage to take you it doesn't mean you remember it super well. I felt guilty too. I knew we weren't well off- and for that first trip my parents leased a van, and I remember the worries over the mileage, and I just really remember worrying a lot. So if you have a sensitive kid and they know how expensive and special WDW is- that can detract from the actual experience.

I would love to take my family back, but I keep running the numbers and can't figure out a way to make it work. The only reason we can go now- and to be clear we are going for our first "visit every park/multi day visit" in December during the week- is because we both work, budget like crazy, travel on the cheap, and don't have kids. I cannot fathom bringing children, or wanting to eat table service, or staying at a deluxe- heck, even art of animation. It's not worth it in my mind.

It is ridiculously expensive for the two of us. I am still working to lower these costs. Added to this is a $55.00 giftcard I got from when they closed down the Disney Vacation Account (which ended one of my other money-back plans). To be fair, buying the AP's means I can get away with spending under $1k (hopefully less) for the two or three trips of two or three nights in 2018. As you can see, I earned the Southwest Companion Pass, which helps with flight costs a lot too. I could technically not spend on airfare using the points I have saved, but I am saving those for 2019-2020, when the companion pass expires. Not sure if we will be coming back to Disney after 2018 for a while- we'll see. We have in our time together spent under $1k to up to $3k on vacations in a given year. So dropping this much on one trip is ballz insane. Hopefully the memories and experiences will be special! We spent slightly more on a new AC/Furnace this year... and those last a decade. We spent 20% of this amount on our couch. My eyebrows are permanently up when I think about Disney, ha! For the longest time I never went anywhere, just worked multiple jobs and threw money at student loans, etc. But I'm getting older, and life isn't promised. I want to have some good experiences with the ones I love while I can. Because who knows if we'll even have retirement in the future- a lot of people are already working through those years to support themselves. I try not to think of this as only a week or I get nauseous. Worth noting that we are counting this as our birthday and Christmas gifts too.

Capture.JPG

When Len talked about the future- I am very interested in this. Obviously, one hopes that there will be global action to try and reduce the negative effects and turn what we can around while we still can, but at this point we need to be prepared for that to not happen. I found this NYT article from June with this infographic:

1.JPG

...Not great. Truly, I hope things change and improve. But even in 2017, as Len was remarking- it is very hot in Florida. That alone rules out a lot of people from attending at points during the year. Heatstroke isn't fun, and is very dangerous.

It is interesting how much deliberate cost finagling the company uses. I loved hearing some of the inside action- and also someone who obviously loves the company critiquing it. I brought up inflation in another thread once and it didn't go well. The costs of those trips are truly high, and it is sad for the people who can only really afford one day that the ticket prices are even higher for them. That's why we got the AP- if you can't stay for long periods to get the savings after four days it adds up fast.
 


Disney is currently deluded into what people's direct deposits say...or to be more specifics: how little they've grown.

Or how much they've shrank!

For my family and I, the last 10 years have been bad. The cost of everything going up, and two pay cuts.

Its harder and harder to justify a Disney vacation. That's one reason why we won't be going back for a very long time after our next trip in 2018.
 
Or how much they've shrank!

For my family and I, the last 10 years have been bad. The cost of everything going up, and two pay cuts.

Its harder and harder to justify a Disney vacation. That's one reason why we won't be going back for a very long time after our next trip in 2018.

I think that is a big point - and put more succinctly than I was thinking. I do know a few families that were huge Disney goers but are now questioning when they go back.

I almost picture in my head a "Cost vs Magic" chart with a diagonal "Happily Ever After Line" ... now the angle that line has will be different for everyone but at some point the costs will be too high that there isn't enough magic to make it worth while. So they need to ensure the Magic stays fresh and at a high enough level to justify the costs
happily Ever After Line.jpg
 
I live in the midwest. Most of our schools do not have air conditioning. It can be very hot here in May and August/September and I have never experienced any health risks myself or seen anyone else experience such a thing. I think you are blowing the health risk piece up a bit. For example just two weeks ago it was in the 90s for several days here while school was in session and never saw anything about any health issues.

Columbus' schools had noon release 2-3 days last week for heat.
 
Or how much they've shrank!

For my family and I, the last 10 years have been bad. The cost of everything going up, and two pay cuts.

Its harder and harder to justify a Disney vacation. That's one reason why we won't be going back for a very long time after our next trip in 2018.

Right...when I said "how little they've grown"...I was attempting to be "sunny side up"...

...I'll never do it again, Mom
 
I don't do football, so to me that is just a worn looking dog mascot attempting to nae nae. Sorry!
The looks I get wearing my UT gear around town are priceless.

Buckeye fans do not mess around up here. I used to get ish for wearing blue or yellow at school. I think it is all juvenile, and not in the fun way.
 
I don't do football, so to me that is just a worn looking dog mascot attempting to nae nae. Sorry!


Buckeye fans do not mess around up here. I used to get ish for wearing blue or yellow at school. I think it is all juvenile, and not in the fun way.

Looked like the PedoSt lion to me.
 

GET A DISNEY VACATION QUOTE

Dreams Unlimited Travel is committed to providing you with the very best vacation planning experience possible. Our Vacation Planners are experts and will share their honest advice to help you have a magical vacation.

Let us help you with your next Disney Vacation!











facebook twitter
Top