okay sorry to bring this thread back from the dead...
but i just got in from seeing 17 again.
i was suuuper blown away. i thought it was gonna be good and it definitely lived up to my expectations.
i'm super picky about my movies too, but 17 again was like...amazing.
probably the second funniest movie i've seen yet this year (next to i love you man)
highly recommend it.
plus....zac efron...shirtless...not complaints here.
also side note, i saw it with my BF and as we were walking to the car he hugged me super tight and was like 'that movie actually made me appreciate you more'
(so that might've helped with my critique a bit too hahaha)
but seriously, it's good! if you haven't seen it already go see it!!!