I love comparing notes!
Last year we stayed October 3-11, so 8N/7D with 6 day base tickets in a pool view room at POP with free dining for $2400. This year, because of the ticket and room type upgrade requirements, our package for 9N/8D is $3120. We opted for the water park & more option because we would be more likely to use that as park hopper and, in all technicality, it acts as a park hopper itself just not within the 4 base parks. If I move to ASSp, I shave it down to $2700. If I reduce it by that extra night, I shave it down an additional $150 which takes the total cost to $2550 for 8N/7D with water parks & more. Only $150 more than last year, so at that point I'm still saving given the extras from the ticket add-on.
Yes, you've convinced me that I'm making the right choice 100%