NorthernCalMom
Compulsive Touring Planner
- Joined
- Jun 20, 2012
Here's my own Google list of Disney mother issues (I'm including yours, too, for sake of completeness):Beauty and the Beast and The Little Mermaid both featured a widower with children
[...]
Snow White in the original story her mom dies
Cinderella in the original story her mom dies
Sleeping Beauty in the original story her mom dies
Snow White: dead mom, evil stepmom
Pinocchio: no mom, though that makes sense in context of the story
Dumbo: traumatic separation from mom
Bambi: no explanation needed
Cinderella: dead mom (yes, it's true that this is due to the original story, but it's still notable that Disney liked picking stories/plots with dead or absent moms)
Sleeping Beauty: mom is not named but visible on the sidelines (in the original Grimm story "Dornroeschen" the mother actually does NOT die but falls with the entire court into a 100-year long sleep with her daughter... no Prince Philipp in that one...); interestingly, the queen is named "Leah" in the Wikipedia entry for the Disney movie, but I don't know where they got that one, I don't think it appears in the movie
Sword in the Stone: Arthur is an orphan
Jungle Book: Mowgli is an orphan
The Rescuers: One of the main characters, Penny, is an orphan
Oliver and Company: orphaned kittens
The Little Mermaid: dead mother
Beauty and the Beast: dead mother
Aladdin: Aladdin is an orphan, Jasmine's mom is dead
Lion King: this one bucks the trend by having dad rather than mom die
Pocahontas: absent or dead mom (she's not mentioned, if I remember correctly)
Tarzan: orphaned
Lilo and Stitch: orphaned
Finding Nemo: dead mom
Ratatouille: no mom
Enchanted: no parents
Princess and the Frog: another outlier, mom is alive, dad is dead (my 9-year old daughter, whose looking over my shoulder as I am writing this, reminded me that Charlotte seems to not have a mom)
Tangled: Flynn Rider is orphaned
Brave: mom is in mortal danger but survives (also, in this one, I love that the mom is an interestingly written character rather than an ornament)
Frozen: dead parents
Big Hero 6: dead parents
In add fairness, we have to consider that many children's and young adult stories to have dead or dying parents in them, partially because trauma and loss tend to drive a story and add danger and urgency to the plot. Also, much of the source material is from fairy tales and older stories, in which child bed fever and other dangerous diseases were still a reality, probably resulting for the many stories that have step moms in them. Looking at the above list, I notice that it's obviously not just the moms, but there are also a good number of dead dads, so that my put a bit of a dent into my theory.
I wonder if some of Walt Disney's issues with loss had to do with his own history. When I read his biography, I found that he did (when he was an adult, it happened in 1938) lose his mom in an accident in a house that he had bought for his parents after his success with Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. According to the Wikipedia entry on Flora Call Disney (citing Pat Williams's "How to Be Like Walt" as source) her death "plagued her son Walt with grief for the rest of his life." So it wouldn't be surprised that he felt drawn to stories that circle around loss and overcoming the adversity and sadness that comes with such losses.
Of course all of this is utterly off topic for this thread (unless we consider the loss of a beloved show a traumatic loss )... It's just something I find extremely interesting.