Hi Gail,
I think it's nice to visit different restaurants. I like the Blue Bayou for lunch (better prices for me), but really, it's up to you on the kind of restaurant experience you'd like. I like the Storyteller Cafe for atmosphere (fireplaces in the dining room). Last year, for Christmas, my brother & I ate at Hook's Pointe, and it was very nice. I like the Jazz Kitchen, also, as it is very good.
If you'd really like to go to Blue Bayou, maybe lunch on one day & dinner the next?