Better Christmas Atmosphere - Liberty Tree Tavern or Diamond Horseshoe

[lorileahb]

Which has the better Christmas atmosphere (decorations? music from the player piano?)... Liberty Tree Tavern or Diamond Horseshoe. I understand the food is now the same. We are going in December - have been to neither, but want to pick the best one for the holidays this trip. We are a table for 2.

 

[JKMastalski]

Definitely Liberty Tree! Diamond Horseshoe is okay for atmosphere - but just one large room. Liberty Tree is definitely cozier.

 

[lorileahb]

Definitely Liberty Tree! Diamond Horseshoe is okay for atmosphere - but just one large room. Liberty Tree is definitely cozier.

Thanks. The one photo I saw of Diamond Horseshoe had a ton of Christmas lights/garland strung around the balcony... wasn't sure how Liberty Tree decorates.

 

[morganms22]

The overall feel at Liberty Tree is definitely more “Christmas” like compared to Diamond Horse Shoe which even with decorations feels more like a saloon to me.