Blue milk or Green milk???

[Imamom2]

I know we want to try it - and we will probably wind up getting both - but I'm thinking the green alcohol version looks best. What have you all tried? Thanks

 

[1andrea]

What’s green alcohol?? X

 

[Imamom2]

What’s green alcohol?? X

You can get an alcohol version of either one - the blue is rum and the green is tequila.

 

[1andrea]

You can get an alcohol version of either one - the blue is rum and the green is tequila.

Haha haha I literally clicked to reply that I prefer red top milk which is skimmed in the UK

 

[mamamelody2]

BLUE is better!

 

[cobright]

The blue is generally better received. I liked it better. That's a nice way of saying I didn't dislike it. I didn't like the green milk at all.

 

[DuskKodesh]

If you want to try both I've heard of people getting it layered. Layer of green, layer of blue.

 

[DharmaLou]

Blue for sure!

 

[MissStitch626]

I enjoy both but like the green slightly better. DH likes the blue slightly better so we'll call it a draw!

 

[loves to dive]

My son and I tried both with alcohol. I lied the green better, he the blue. Both needed to be stirred a lot, I'm talking at least 3 min. before trying it. They put a lot of alcohol in it.

 

[Imamom2]

If you want to try both I've heard of people getting it layered. Layer of green, layer of blue.

Oohhh now I'm intrigued! I think that will be the one we choose. Thanks

 

[RealBlast3]

I wonder if they use like Blue Curacao for the blue to color it. I've had that before in mixed drinks. As for the green, the greens I know are Midori Melon liquor and Creme de menthe and I guess Sour Appletini liquors.

Of course, it could always just be food coloring. But I have never heard of those going into mixed drinks.

 

[evlaina]

I tried both, non-alcoholic (shared with my 6 year old). We both hated the green, it tasted liked lawn clippings smell lol. Blue was fine and my daughter liked it, but neither of us had more than a couple sips, and that was only because it was like 100 degrees.

FYI we mobile ordered, thinking that would pass the line, but the CMs didn't even notice they had a mobile order until everyone in the regular line was gone. I just stood there until one guy noticed me. Depending on the line, I would just wait.

 

[eeyoreandtink]

I wonder if they use like Blue Curacao for the blue to color it. I've had that before in mixed drinks. As for the green, the greens I know are Midori Melon liquor and Creme de menthe and I guess Sour Appletini liquors.

Of course, it could always just be food coloring. But I have never heard of those going into mixed drinks.

The milk itself is already blue or green and non alcoholic. They add either rum or tequila after the fact, so I am sure the coloring is food coloring.

 

[OfCourseTheresAlwaysMyWay]

I second that mobile order here is useless. Only place where I encountered that.

Blue is better, but neither of them are great. I think the blue milk tastes like Flight of Passage smells. So that's either a plus or a minus depending on your POV.

My friend who is a CM says everyone prefers both flavors with alcohol, but I tried both of mine without it.

 

[cobright]

The milk itself is already blue or green and non alcoholic. They add either rum or tequila after the fact, so I am sure the coloring is food coloring.

This is true. But I was reading about the stuff and apparently the colorings are naturally derived plant extracts. Like not "natural flavors and colors" but actually in the form of a plant...
Yes, the Blue color is Spirulina extract. The green is a mix of spirulina, turmeric, and beta carotene.

 

[nycdisneygal]

We tried both NON alcoholic and they were both good. We got one of each and shared with the kids. I liked both but the blue a little better and my husband liked the green a little better.

 

[Haley R]

Dh and I tried both non alcoholic. I thought for sure I would like blue better but I actually liked the green a lot more. Dh was the opposite and liked the blue better.

 

[DGsAtBLT]

We only tried blue (no alcohol) and it wasn’t bad but wasn’t what I expected. It was way more fruity and more slushy like than I expected something called milk to be.

 

[SteveH]

Can I just skip the fake milk and get the shot? Oh wait, I forgot it's Bacardi. Never mind.