California Grill or Narcoossee's?

[TNKim]

We will be staying at BLT for the first time at the end of May and I'm debating between these two for our more expensive meal. I have been to Narcoosee's once before and loved it. But since we will be at BLT, it would make sense to try California Grill. Without fireworks at MK, is California Grill still a good choice? I don't want to be disappointed since I loved Narcoossee's so much! Also, we are hoping for breakfast ADR at Toppolino's, but not sure about eating at the same restaurant for breakfast and dinner on the same trip when there are so many other places to try. Has anyone had breakfast and dinner at the same place?

 

[Ross Kratter]

California Grill is wonderful. I've been several times, and the best meal I had there was this past January. Truly exquisite.

 

[Micca]

If you're staying at BLT Calif. Grill is def. the choice.

 

[hedberg1661]

CG is one of my favorites on property. It's a very cool experience fireworks or not.

 

[ineedavacation33]

We ate at both in the same trip last November (we go to California Grill often on our trips) and had no complaints on either meal. I'd still choose California Grill, for the selection of food, atmosphere, and service. It feels like a "fancier" dining experience, although the actual price tags are similar.

 

[ZellyB]

I'd also vote for California Grill. Just ate there last week and it was fabulous as usual.

 

[ENJDisneyFan]

Another vote for CG!! It’s amazing

 

[gharter]

We are doing both next month.
If I had to choose one, California Grill.

 

[Olaf Myfrenzargay]

California Grill during fireworks was epic. Without fireworks, would still go.

 

[DisneyHardin]

We've eaten at both and really enjoy them both. But, if you are only going to do one "fancy" meal, I would say California Grill - like the above posters have said - it just seems a little classier.

 

[OKW Lover]

I'd go with Narcoossee's. Not a fan of CG. They seem to trade on the view more than the food/service at CG. Narcoossee scores well on all counts.

 

[GeorgiaHoo]

We liked Narcoossee's and would return, but the California Grill brunch was the best meal we've had at Disney. Not sure about dinner there.

 

[MomOTwins]

We ate at both last year and CG was hands down better across all fronts. Ambiance, food, drinks—everything was just a little nicer at CG. Bonus points if you go at sunset—the view is just gorgeous

 

[lorimay]

We were at BLT last month and had Narcoose reservations and a CG opened up and we grabbed it.
This was our 2nd time at CG and it was a delicious relaxing meal. The waiter was wonderful, the meal was not rushed and just a great place to spend a couple hours. The first time we did see the fireworks, this time of course we didn't, but still a great night.
If you haven't tried CG, give it a try, you won't be dissapointed.
The pork tenderloin is amazing!!!

 

[TNKim]

We were at BLT last month and had Narcoose reservations and a CG opened up and we grabbed it.
This was our 2nd time at CG and it was a delicious relaxing meal. The waiter was wonderful, the meal was not rushed and just a great place to spend a couple hours. The first time we did see the fireworks, this time of course we didn't, but still a great night.
If you haven't tried CG, give it a try, you won't be dissapointed.
The pork tenderloin is amazing!!!

I guess I should have mentioned that we will have 2 15 year old boys with us. Is California Grill too fancy for teen boys? In looking at the menu, I’m not sure they will like the sides that come with the pork, filet or chicken.

 

[Jml813]

I wouldn't say it's too fancy. I would say it's a little more approachable and I think they would like it. I like CG and like others have said, it's my favorite restaurant on Disney property.

 

[ENJDisneyFan]

I guess I should have mentioned that we will have 2 15 year old boys with us. Is California Grill too fancy for teen boys? In looking at the menu, I’m not sure they will like the sides that come with the pork, filet or chicken.

My boys (11 and 14) love it. But it’s $$ !!

 

[mrsap]

Narcoossee’s for me. Food and service is always excellent.

 

[Kelly loves Food]

I guess I should have mentioned that we will have 2 15 year old boys with us. Is California Grill too fancy for teen boys? In looking at the menu, I’m not sure they will like the sides that come with the pork, filet or chicken.

You can always sub the sides for something they will enjoy. They can swap them for anything else on the menu with no issue

 

[lovin'fl]

CG. We just tried Narcoossees for thr 1st time and it did not wow.
My very picky DDs-22 like CG. And they have a young palette. One moreso than the other. But she enjoyed the CG brunch a couple years back.