That's a tough choice to me, I love both resorts. We've stayed at WL twice and CR twice, we'll be staying at CR a 3rd time in June. CR rooms are definitely a good bit larger than the WL rooms. I love the atmosphere at the WL, the grand lobby, all the lodge-y decor. And the boat service to MK is really nice. CR has a great quick service in the Contempo Cafe and you just can't beat being able to walk back and forth to the MK, which is my favorite park. CR wins out more with the rest of my family, we all love being right next to the MK, and for my kids (DS 14, DD12, DS8) they just love having the monorail right there in the hotel with us. Yes, as the previous poster said, it can feel a bit like an airport terminal, but to me it's still magical with the MK being right there, with the castle in plain view.