The things OP did not like about Kidani are exactly what has been mentioned most often as the downsides for Kidani: only a table service restaurant and no quick service or breakfast option, and the very long walks (and they can be very long: it is about 1/3 mile from the lobby to the end of the north wing, and more than 1/3 mile from end of south wing to the pool). The thing OP mentioned as liking about Kidani -- the impressive 2BR -- is exactly what most have mentioned as one of the best features of Kidani, the spacious and very nice 1 and 2BRs. On both sides of the equation I agree with the OP but reallly like staying at Kidani including because of the impressive 2BRs (and under-building parking). I can live without quick service or the breakfast option even though they would be nice to have (and I disagree with the logic of not including a quick service; someone concluded it would not be used enough to be profitable because Disney would put one in if it would have been profitable, but I question the belief that it would not be used enough).
The thing is every resort has its upsides and downsides (e.g., BCV has a great location but not an impressive view anywhere, BWV has great location, very impressive boardwalk view, but has no quick service and long walks to the elevator, VWL has a good location, nice boat rides, but really has only one main view: "trees," OKW has the largest rooms but limited restaurant options, long walks to amenities from most rooms, and is not near a park, likewise SSR has the unique treehouses, two feature pools, can walk to golf, but long walks to most places and not near a park, BLT has large and impressive 1 and 2BRs, many rooms with good views, and easy access to MK, but too small studios, questionable lower floor "theme park' view rooms, no restaurant options in the building and the bad (such as the stark, stone wall look) of the inside of the Contemporary (although the Contemporary has its own benefits-- there is likely no better character meal resataurant than Chef Mickey's; I have not been to VGF yet). In other words, depending on the individuals, one can walk away from any DVC resort happy or disappointed because none is anywhere near perfect. My personal preferences are BWV with boardwalk view and Kidani dedicated savanna view 2BRs, also like BLT for high floor lake view and SSR if I can get Congress Park view (that is a request that is usually met); no real desire to stay again at OKW, BCV, or VWL)