[I just read this thread. And I’ve checked in for a cruise (on
DCL) twice in the last year. But I must have cleared my memory (real one, not computer). And check-in for all cruises gets muddled together. So forgive me if I am way off on anything.]
Everyone is checking in at the same time? Yikes. As many have pointed out, Disney IT is not known for great quality.
It’s been 11 years since I had to pick a time but I would accept
not having a ”show up anytime PAT.” … But I think they could return to staggered check-in dates, allowing priority in selecting PAT based on Castaway level. It would still give a benefit for loyalty while allowing for control of passenger flow during check-in. And once testing is gone, consider a return to the days of anytime PAT for Platinum. (But do they really need to space out check-in at 15 day increments? It has to be tough reading others’ success in acquiring reservations and having to wait months to try yourself.)
As to why an early arrival - time on the ship. Already mentioned is the opportunity to eat lunch just hours before early seating for dinner. Or even getting to eat in Cabanas or an MDR at all.
… Smart, savvy cruisers - especially those on the short cruises - know that boarding day pool time has typically been one of the best times to get pool access without being in people soup.
And then there is onboard booking for Palo, etc., or making reservations for Hyperspace. Early bird often gets the worm. (And those who spend part of their cruise checking for cancellations.
…. Yes, early seating is a “reward” for booking early. And has to be requested, as Second Seating is the default, no matter your Castaway Level.