Hi all!
I am currently booked rack rate at POFQ for 11/28-12/2. We stayed at POFQ in 2016 and absolutely loved it. (We loved the small feel, the transportation was the best of anywhere we stayed on property, the theming was great, and the pool was awesome.)
I love both resorts and I switch off staying between the two of them. From what you just said here, regardless of everything else, I'd go with FQ, just because it sounds like the right "fit" for you, and then you can go over to Riverside and check it out/swim in that pool while you are there.
I have the option of switching to an agency exclusive deal at POR that will save me close to $100/night. DH is all for it, but I am hesitant for several reasons.
It's not that different between the two (IMO) that it should cause a fight, meaning if one of you feels more strongly what you should do, just go with it. Again, whichever you choose you can go to the other hotel to swim, shop, eat, etc...
1) Pop Warner week- we are teachers so being around loosely supervised kids and teens at our resort is not something we want. Plus there is the possibility of running into some students/parents while we play hookey.
How likely is it that Pop Warner/cheer groups will be staying at POR?
Not likely at all, neither Port hotel is a part of the Pop Warner deal for 2018 as far as I know (someone correct me if I'm wrong).
2) Size of the resort is intimidating to me. With our deal we’d be in a standard room. We want to swim in the Ol’ Man Island Pool a ton because my kids are obsessed with water slides.
How far of a walk is it from the super far standard rooms to Ol’ Man Island pool?
It is bigger, so that is one thing that definitely a positive for FQ if you want a really short walk anywhere. I don't mind a walk in Riverside because it's beautiful, so I haven't really ever timed out the walks, and they don't bother me.
3) Transportation. I’m reading reports of people waiting at their bus stops within the resort and having full buses pass them. They’re waiting forever to get on a bus. (We’ve only ever stayed at resorts that have a single bus stop in the past.)How is the transportation? And how far of a walk is it from the furthest rooms to the first bus stop should we want to wait up there instead?
I've never had that issue, but there are 4 stops, so you can pick which you want to go to at Riverside. I usually use a mix of the main stop, and the one closest to my room.
4) Christmasy feel. I want to hear a steady stream of Christmas classics and see decorations everywhere. From a few tours I’ve watched of POR Christmas it doesn’t seem like they do much.
Has anyone been there at Christmas? How is it?
I like Christmas at both resorts, the trees are really pretty, if there is a difference, I'd say FQ is just a bit more colorful.
I like trying out new Disney hotels, so that is something to consider. But if you have your heart set on FQ, then Riverside may not be able to win you over. But, like I said, I love 'em both, so whichever you go with, I hope you have a great trip!