We must have similar tastes since we also love Pecos Bills and don't care for Restaurantosaurus either. We also like the Cantina and Yakitori House in Epcot. I don't know where you'll be staying but we like Roaring Forks in the WL, Mara in AKL, and I know it's not counter service but we love Beaches and Cream at the BC. The one truly BAD counter service we've had was at Rosie's All American Cafe which is outdoor seating in MGM as you walk towards TOT and RNRC. It may have been a fluke but my cheeseburger was truly inedible. One bite and it made me lose my appetite. It was cold and had a very weird taste to it. It surprised me that it was cold because it was extremely busy and we waited in a long line so you'd think the food would be turning over quickly. I also didn't like it there because it was so crowded that while I looked for a table while dh was in line a table opened up and this man (not going to say gentleman) literally pushed me aside to get to it first. Another couple who were almost ready to leave saw it and waved me and the kids over and invited us to sit down and that we could have their table since they were ready to leave (which proves for every rude person you run into there are many nice folks too). Then dh brought the "food" over and people were literally hovering over ours and others shoulders waiting to pounce and we had JUST gotten our food. I hate that! Of course it wasn't nearly as awful as what I witnessed once in Pizzafari when a man LITERALLY pulled a chair out from under a lady in her 60's but I've posted that here before so I don't want to be redundant and bore y'all (but I still can't believe what I saw!)