I love PCH better than Goofy's also. However, Donald Duck now hosts the PCH Surf's Up. I really prefer Storytellers over eithe rof them, and now Storytellers has Mickey, Minnie, Chip, Dale, and Pluto. The interaction at SToryteller and PCH are much better than Goofy's. For food, it is Storyteller, PCH, Goofy's, and Plaza Inn.I would go PCH all the way. Goofy's kitchen is crowded, loud and expensive when PCH offers pretty much the same meal (minus a few specialties I don't think are worth the extra $$), is calmer since it's less well-known and also much more personal time with the characters. The one time I went to Goofy's we barely met everyone over a 2 hour meal, but every trip to PCH has been full of character interactions and my kid has danced with Daisy and Minnie so many times that they started copying his moves. I also prefer having our photo with surf Mickey than Chef Goofy but that is probably a personal opinion. Another point is that I have almost always been able to walk into PCH with or without a reservation. The same isn't true for Goofy's so that is another plus in the PCH column if you ask me.
I love PCH better than Goofy's also. However, Donald Duck now hosts the PCH Surf's Up. I really prefer Storytellers over eithe rof them, and now Storytellers has Mickey, Minnie, Chip, Dale, and Pluto. The interaction at SToryteller and PCH are much better than Goofy's. For food, it is Storyteller, PCH, Goofy's, and Plaza Inn.