We only did Goofy's Kitchen and Ariel's for dinner, and of the two, I thought Goofy's was better. The characters did not seem as rushed (Cinderella just blazed through and I almost didn't get an autograph), and you have more choices because it was a buffet. The food at Ariel's was quite good (not great), perhaps it depends on what you order. Goofy's Kitchen also had a mix of great and good dishes. DD was under 3, so she did not get the bucket with the dinner. Of course, having all the Princesses there at once without having to wait in line was great! We had Belle, Snow White, Sleeping Beauty, Ariel with legs, and Cinderella. I wanted to see Jasmine but no such luck ... The waiters were great at both places.
By the way, Belle in her village outfit was at Goofy's Kitchen - I did not expect that.
By the way, Belle in her village outfit was at Goofy's Kitchen - I did not expect that.