We ended up getting to go on our trip. We checked out this morning. Quick report:
We rented bikes for the first time. It was so awesome to be able to ride around the island with great weather. We will be back in June and not sure if we will rent them then as it’s so hot.
We did a Kroger pickup and ate breakfasts and lunches in the room. We ended up going out to eat some for dinner. We ate outside only and very early like around 4-4:30. Here’s a quick run-down of the restaurants we went to.
Skull Creek Boathouse: I was surprised this wasn’t very crowded. We actually went thinking we would do take-out but since there were few people we decided to stay. We were seated in their new pavilion which was very nice. There were only two other groups in there when we arrived. The tables were spaced far apart. Probably the best social distancing of all the places we ate at. The food was amazing as usual. The only complaint I had was that our server had on a bandana instead of a mask.
Steamer Seafood: This is in a new location so we weren’t sure if they had outdoor seating. They did, so we decided to stay. The outdoor section was small. There were about three other groups, and I felt that the tables were a little close. Unfortunately, the tables were bolted to the ground so we couldn’t scoot farther away. I felt a little uncomfortable there, but that's coming from someone who hasn't eaten at a restaurant since February. The food was good as usual. Definitely try the shrimp cocktail if you want a little kick!
Poseidon: I love this place! We ate outside overlooking the marsh. I love their early bird menu, especially the surf and turf. There were several groups here, but we were very spaced out. Very good social distancing going on there.
Fishcamp at Broad Creek: This was the second time we have eaten here, and it will probably be our last. Both times we have gotten poor service. This time our meals were much better though. I loved my scallops and was able to sub the risotto for mashed potatoes. Please no flames, but we just can’t get over the fact that they allow dogs in their outdoor seating area. We love dogs, but we just don’t want to be around them when we’re eating. We've had this issue both times we've visited. This place was horrible for social distancing! We asked to be moved from the first table they sat us at, right by the bar and where everyone walked past. We were able to get a fairly isolated spot beside the fans. The fans probably made it safer for us, but not those seated around us. I know others have said their experiences were good as far as social distancing, but we thought their outdoor area had way too many people and would not recommend!
Other notes—We walked into the French Bakery in Shelter Cove one day around 9:00 a.m. and turned around and walked right out. No social distancing going on there at all. Very crowded. People packed together at the counter to order. Tables close together. Very scary! Also, the beach was more crowded than I've ever seen, and that's even compared to summer! Both times we went there to ride bikes or walk, we wore our masks, but we were the only ones on the entire beach who had masks (at least that we saw). We felt the most comfortable at the Disney resort and on the bike trails where you would meet/pass individuals briefly.
Hope this helps those who will be going soon.