Just wanted to thanks everyone for all the Costa Rica tips. I have decided to replicate the itinerary that
@CyndiLouWho posted with a some modifications. DH loves to drive so we'll be getting a rental car - need to do more research on that. Since we are going during spring break I need to stay on top of making reservations. I already have Hyatt Andaz Costa Rica Resort at Peninsula Papagayo booked for 3 nights, the itinerary calls for 2 nights in that area but I would love to add a rest day - it will all come down to flights schedules.
Can someone recommend a hotel near Manuel Antonio National Park entrance?