I am going to give you a recommendation which provides for very versatile rewards, but may not be ideal for your Disney vacation. I recommend each of you get a Chase Sapphire Preferred card. Right now, there's an offer for 80,000 Chase Ultimate Reward (URs) points for spending $4,000 in 3 months, $95 Annual Fee. Here's the steps:
- Ideally, use a support link from someone here on Dischurners (you'll be invited if you aren't already a member) and open a card for P1 (player1).
- Once that card is open, P1 creates a support link for the other spouse, and that spouse opens the same card, earning 20,000 UR support points.
Don't add each other as authorized users on each others cards- as that will limit the number of new cards you can open in a 24 month period. When applying, you may use "household income" as your income, so your personal income level won't be relevant.
The above steps will earn you these URs:
80,000 P1 card
4,000 P1 spending $4,000 and earning at least 1point/$1
20,000 support points
80,000 P2 card
4,000 P2 spending $4,000 and earning at least 1point/$1
--------------
188.000 points
The problem with Chase points is that you can't use those points to purchase Disney tickets or book Disney properties. You could however use it to book hotels near Disney through the portal. If you use the portal, each point is worth 1.25 cents, so 188,000 points would be worth $2350! And you can combine URs within the same household, so you can essentially pool your points together to making booking easier.
There are also Pay Yourself Back categories, which is essentially using points to erase the purchase cost. Right now for the CSP, those categories are AirBNB and dining. So if you spend a lot in those categories, you can erase $2350 using those 188,000 points. Some people will mentally take that savings from their everyday dining spend, and then apply that towards their Disney tickets. Hope that makes sense. Feel free to ask more questions.