Some threads just never die...
My "sad story" happened in October of 2006...since then I've had two extraordinarily positive experiences renting from a DISBoard member, and two equally good experiences where I shared some points I didn't need with others (both people I "met" here on the DIS)...
So, out of five experiences, four were way beyond "just good" and one was bad--cost me $800, and that's not good, but it could have been much worse...I didn't arrive at Disney to find no accommodations; I didn't have to spend a lot of time worrying (lost it quickly!)...
So...from my experience (whether or not as the OP of the "Sad Story" thread makes any difference!), renting is good!
I'm really sorry to see all the new restrictions on using the R/T Board...(I'm also really sorry to see the new restrictions on using the waitlist--both make renting --both to and from -- exponentially more difficult)...but rules are rules and life goes on...
Good luck to all seeking to rent (to and from!)...
Dani