I did the Before years ago, terrace. We were one of the first in, enjoyed out desserts, enjoyed the fireworks and we were promptly shoo'd out and desserts were covered.
Last week we did the After Party. As soon as we checked in we were allowed to head to the Plaza Garden. Showed our band and entered. We had first pick of where we wanted to sit. The garden never filled up but there was a good number of people in there.
We were told over and over that everyone had to stay seated for the show ... then the people closest to the center of the hub began to stand and about 1/4 of the folks were all standing. There seemed to be some confusion and folks sitting over there that had been told no one would be allowed to stand (I was originally over there and moved to the middle) were getting upset. With only one CM in the garden, it was difficult for him to manage all. 3/4 of the garden stayed seated.
We had a full family sneak in and that led to some fun .... they were actually ones worried some would stand and block their view. I guess once he saw they had no bands he asked everyone to raise their arms to show their bands. They did but showed their magicbands. A few folks side eyed them. Then he said again everyone raise your arms to show your party bands. They didn't and everyone was staring at them. He told them it was a private event that they had to pay to sit there. It was clear they were fully prepared, dad and kids didn't blink, Mom responded unpleasantly. There was a second situation. Not sure if it was due to all who stood there or all those in the walkway in front standing ... in addition to us sitting ... but one family unleashed on the CMs about the view at the dessert party and managers were all showing up because it was getting loud. Certainly understand if they were disappointed about something BUT .... no reason to be that ugly.
As we headed to party, they were verbally shooing the terrace folks out. Our After Party was not crowded (I still don't think they PR it enough - like year one DAH), we could pick our table so we picked with view of castle since they were doing Once Upon. The desserts were certainly not the quality we had years ago. They had the ice cream sundae stuff, the fresh fruit, cookies, brownie, rice crispy ..... nothing special there. They had maybe 5-6 specialty desserts. They were making smores on a stick, none of us liked them and didn't finish. Loved that they had the Oooey Gooey Toffee Cake and I had ice cream on mine. There was cheese, hamburger egg rolls, I think some crackers and dips .... I didn't pay too much attention to it. Coffees, a couple juices, tea, lemonade, milk and sparkling cider.
Food wise I was disappointed, especially with the specialty ones quality. One was grey stuff on an oreo and a chocolate mickey face ...... store bought OREO! But I was also comparing it to years ago and Star Wars Weekends Dessert Parties, which were awesome ... maybe things have just changed.
We were not rushed we were told we had a full 45 minutes after we got there but we didn't stay that long. We finished up our plates. Did I get my monies worth? No. I don't see myself repeating it. I do think the After Party was more relaxed and better for getting in garden than the Before Party.
INTERESTING PART:
DS2 and friend were booked for After Party. They booked immediately when announced. It was her first trip and he didn't want her to deal with the hub crush and she likes desserts. I had decided to not do it and DS1 and I would just do more rides. WELL ... we were walking them to the podium and DS1 (who is disabled) got so excited because he thought we were going to. Face was priceless ........... So I went on
MDE but booking was not possible. I went to the podium and asked if it was possible to book on the spot. I know in trips past I'd see them at their podium during the day selling open spots. Well they said yes ... I followed them up to a register on a cart up by the TT windows and she rang me up on the spot. So if you can't get ... as soon as those podiums go up during the day keep checking.