A lot of movies that have teacher scenes are ridiculous. The madonna/(something that rhymes with "more") dichotomy is big in portrayals of teachers (Ex: "Overboard" & "Matilda"), but some films are just plain silly in their portrayals. Off the top of my head:
- "Teachers", the movie where the school's lawyer walks naked down the school hallway, and a long-term substitute is actually a runaway mental patient (um, yeah)
- "Overboard", in which a rotten teacher punishes a child who is obviously sick
- "Matilda", in which the syrupy-sweet teacher speaks in a fatuously earnest manner. We do love and enjoy kids, but I've taught for 20 years and never witnessed a real teacher talking like that.
- "School of Rock" is actually a movie I like but its premise is something that could never happen (given a real classroom of kids, most would squeal immediately- they're just not good secret-keepers). Also, asking colleagues about their standardized test preferences is not our idea of interesting lunch conversation.
-"Lean on Me", which purposefully spread the idea that teachers deserve to be abused by administration due to the fact that many students at the violent and impoverished school were low-performing. Pediatricians who serve low income communities don't get screamed at for having many obese children as patients (a good doctor would fix that, and never mind about the child's parents with few cooking skills who are feeding him Cokes & Twinkies for dinner, the fact that they live in a food desert with no produce or lean meats readily available anyway, or the fact that he has nowhere to do sports or play), but somehow it's okay for teachers to get screamed at for having academically challenged students. SMH.
-"Doubt", set in a Catholic school in the early 1960s, in which two over-vigilant nun teachers conspire to get the principal/priest they wrongly suspect of sexual abuse to remove himself from the school. Yeah, that kind of hypervigilant monitoring of potential sexual abuse in Catholic schools happened all the time back then and was the real story that the Boston Globe didn't cover, uh huh.
A couple of films I've seen that have shown realistic teachers & eschew the madonna/(something that rhymes with "more") complex that Hollywood has about teachers:
-"Fortress" the storyline (even though very loosely based on a true story) is not anything likely to happen, but the teacher's classroom behavior was realistic.
-"Music of the Heart" featured Meryl Streep as a believable and funny music teacher dealing with realistic situations.