I would as well. I think that those of us who are Disney "frequent fliers" have been taken for granted and left unrewarded in many ways. While I do not think that there needs to be a huge financial reward for loyalty, there really should be more than "welcome back" after answering the question regarding the number of trips we have taken. A BB is nice, but how about something that costs Disney nothing to very little, such as a few anytime FP or maybe a nice additional meal at the resort you choose, or vouchers for appetizers. Something to let you know you are valued.
SO here's the thing. They know you're coming back regardless. They know I'm coming back. They don't need to give us bigger incentives because we've already been hooked. They want to entice those people who were on the fence or never even considered a Disney trip until an amazing deal came along. I have a friend who has been talking about Disney for YEARS. She's finally going this Summer because it works out for their family schedule and "Free Dining"
I wish they offered things to frequent attenders, too. We didn't renew our APs this year because it's now over 6K for my family just to have passes. We spend thousands of dollars in hotels, food, and merchandise. Every single year.