I love it...and over the top, cluttery, WDW theming is one of the reasons I've loved the Swolphin so dearly for so long (can't wait to see the kids walk in on Sunday!!!). It'd take away from WDW/USO though if they didn't have all those crazy themey resorts though and they are so fun to visit; but there are definitely people who don't want to come back to a hotel with a bunch of creepy masks on the walls or being drug into a cabin like WL. WDW/USO is trying to cover everyone's preferences and that's what makes it awesome.
The rooftop bar? Yes, please.