I think maybe you misunderstood what I was trying to say. It’s true that the very first people to actually get to the ride with the first boarding group will have a zero minute wait. BUT those people waited for upwards of 2 hours outside the gate. So best case scenario they waited 2 hours to ride. And a boring wait at that.
I didn't think it was very boring, I spent a lot of it talking to the CM manning the turnstile... it goes by a lot quicker than you would think. With smartphones is it possible to really be bored anywhere anymore?
And that is a best case scenario. There is no guarantee that once you scan in that you’re immediately going to be able to book your boarding group in time to be in the first group called.
Here I disagree. If you are first or second through the turnstile, you'll always be able to get first, or at worst the second group - even with some delay in the app. That happened to me last Saturday, the app delayed a bit and I got second... but if I used the strategy someone just mentioned today, of walking straight over to a CM with an iPad while trying the app along the way over, I am pretty sure being 1st or second through the turnstile would always mean being in the first boarding group. Most people are using phones so the iPad people are not very busy.
If you end up in group 15 or so, then you’re going to be met with the same 30ish minute wait to the preshow that everyone averages throughout the day.
Getting there before 5am each day I never got close to that high a boarding group, for three days in a row. I also never had to wait more than about 10 minutes on my first ride, sometimes walking straight on, sometimes stopping at the equipment rack with the X-wing helmets which is very near where they take you into the briefing room.
Add to that most days so far the ride has broken down in the first hour while loading anywhere from
Group 12-25. That means unless you were one of the very first ones on, you’re now either evacuated and have to come back and wait again or stuck waiting additional time in line.
Yes, which is why it's so incredibly valuable to be first, or at the very least on the ride when it breaks down. Because then at least you'l have had a partial run through the ride and can enjoy it a second time when you come back.
I am by no means saying you shouldn’t line up at 4am. Anything could happen and the earlier the boarding group the better chance you have. I’m just saying everyone should think about what that actually gets them
I don't think 4am is necessary but I do think sometime before 5am is enough to guarantee a front (or very near front) position on the turnstiles, which is all important for getting one of the first boarding groups.
and if it’s actually worth it to them. What it gets you is essentially a ride earlier in the day.
What it gets you is not just an earlier ride, it's a ride with less wait and a much higher chance that you will rude uninterrupted. All of those have a lot of value. I agree people need to evaluate what is important to them, some people simply cannot be there that early. But after multiple days it's pretty clear to me what the value is and what you can obtain, which I have laid out here.
Don't forget some days people had multiple ride attempts through a day that were ended and they never did even get to complete a ride.
Yes, you’ll ride before the people who got there later. But the point of rope dropping the new attractions in the past (other than maybe on opening days) was not to ride it as early as possible. It was to avoid long waits and make sure you get to ride. There is now a much easier way to accomplish those 2 things.
From where I am sitting it does not seem that way, as by chance a later boarding group may never get a complete ride, or have to come back a second day to do so. The virtual BG help a ton in that in-between attempts you have much less standing in line. But the chance of accomplishing a ride in one day drops after the first few boarding groups.
If the ride were 100% stable I would totally agree with your assessment, but too many people are not even getting to complete a ride during a single day visit - if my whole goal of visiting the park was to ride this ride, showing up pre 5am presents as much a guarantee of this as you can possibly have. For some people it may be less important and showing up later is fine, but for someone who is reading this massive thread of posts I have to imagine the desire to actually ride is much more keen than the average park visitor.
Again, I am not telling anyone that has one shot to ride this to take any risks. But I do think there is very little risk involved in arriving at 6:15
Showing up then ensures you are riding sometime after the first breakdown, and at least one of the days from next week onward until after new years I am pretty sure arriving at that time means you will not get a boarding group.
Showing up before 5am is only a bit over an hour difference and then you are riding in the morning, probably four to five hours ahead of someone who arrived at 6:15am - and that is probably best case for the 6:15am people.
Probably sometime later in January arriving at 6:15am will carry no risk, though the ride is so good even then I'm not sure it will die down that much... wait times are still pretty bad for the best rides in any park. I really hope they can increase stability of the ride and open the full capacity soon, which would help tremendously. It could run so many people through It so quickly if it would just operate smoothly... I think it could handle visitor demand if it were running at full tilt.