I wanted to come back and update everyone in hopes my info will be helpful to someone else!
We took her to babies r us and tried all the strollers. That Baby Jogger City Micro sure does turn easily, but it was quite heavy and more than just a little expensive! If I was interested in renting in general, that would be a great one. If my bum were a tiny bit smaller I could have sat in there myself (my hips are 44" wide). So no worries about a kid outgrowing that one!
They did not have the Ignite or the Jet. It is carried by Walmart but they didn't have any on display.
We ended up liking the Volo the best. My kid's measurements are above, and her head peeked up over the top of the backrest but about 70% of it was below it. We told her to pretend she was napping
and she just tucked her head down and she was totally fine.
However the Volo runs about $130, which was a bit beyond our budget. I found a couple on Craigslist for $25; great deals but neither had the canopy. I looked on Ebay and found them for $60 brand new. It even has the hinge covers installed due to the recall, so it's in all respects the same as a totally brand new one. I could have asked for a better color, but the charcoal won't show the dirt
The handles are indeed quite tall and neither my 6'1" husband nor my 5'7" self had any issue with them. I wandered around the store TRYING to kick the back and couldn't. Him either. The thing is also so light I could pick it up and pitch it across the room if I wanted to (not that I want to). While I'm a strong gal, I didn't want something that would be a hassle. We carry on all our luggage so we have 3 small suitcases rather than 1 large one, so we don't want to have to fuss with it.
My daughter loves it. I am going to have to hide it so I'm not pushing her around in it all the time now! While we were test driving it in the store a woman walked up and told us all about how much she loved hers and how fabulous it was and we should buy it.
My husband really dug the sturdy metal frame. He said we should have gotten this one instead of the cheapy one we had when she was tiny. Live and learn!
Thank you for all the help!