We just sold our Boulder Ridge contract and have been considering our next move. One thing I do know is that I love the Boardwalk area (which is where we typically used our BRV points) but I'm not planning to buy into DVC at the moment based on current economic conditions and I don't plan to buy another 2042 contract.
So that brings us to Swan/Dolphin.
If you were a couple, who visits WDW apprx every other year, and stays roughly 4-5 nights each trip, do you feel Swan/Dolphin is a good alternative? To be honest the prices look reasonable, I like the idea of earning Marriott points, and the location is awesome (especially the Swan) since we love walking to Epcot and DHS. It doesn't seem like you really give up any perks vs. staying at a WDW property other than charging off to a magic band which I couldn't care less about. Am I overlooking anything here? Thanks!
I love Swan and Dolphin, but I typically prefer to stay in the “Disney Bubble” if possible- except for during Christmas. This is my favorite Christmas hotel. As much as I love the bubble, though, I don’t love it enough to pay $600+ a night at Boardwalk/Yacht and Beach, when I can often get the Swolphin for under $200/night.
Some other things to consider besides being out of the bubble:
No magic band charging, no magical express, no Disney gift cards, and having to factor in “resort fees” into the price (resort fees irk me). If you’re used to DVC rooms, there also will not be a microwave in the room.
Prices also drastically fluctuate here. I’ve gotten the Dolphin for $85/night (a steal!) but also have seen the prices at over $1,000/night. If your dates are always set, it would be hard to budget.
It does draw a lot of convention crowds, so the other guests can be hit or miss.
One other potential negative, is you mentioned earning Marriott points. Marriott points don’t get you much these days. By a rough calculation, you’d have to do stay about 167 nights before you’d get one of your 4-5 night trips for free (plus you’d still have to pay resort fees). The Marriott credit cards aren’t much help in this area anymore either. Although if you travel frequently elsewhere and stay in Marriotts, you’d get better bang for your buck.
So enough with the negatives, I will tell you that this hotel has an unbeatable location, an amazing pool, great restaurants, and it’s beautiful. I think you’ll love it here!