WDW Restaurant Survey: Table Service Edition!(Final Results!!)

[gatordoc]

OK, 3 worst: 1. Hollywood and Vine 2. T-Rex 3. Turf Club

 

[DisneyFansInNYC]

If I do this again, it would be interesting to allow people to vote for their 3 worst restaurants as well. 5, 3 and 1 points would be subtracted from those restaurant's overall score.

I'd have the 1. Plaza, 2. Captain's Grille and 3.Tony's Town Square.

Oh well, may be next time!

I would say CRT. Truly the worst meal we had on property. This was many years ago - but after spending almost $500 for lunch - I can't get myself to go back. Everyone was so hungry afterwards.

 

[goofy4prez]

If I do this again, it would be interesting to allow people to vote for their 3 worst restaurants as well. 5, 3 and 1 points would be subtracted from those restaurant's overall score.

I'd have the 1. Plaza, 2. Captain's Grille and 3.Tony's Town Square.

Oh well, may be next time!

For fun here are my top three DIShonorable restaurants. ( I know, it's bad)

1. Chef Mickey- Example of mass produced, institutional Golden Coral quality food sitting on a table to be scooped up by droves of people. And very loud.
2. 1900 PF - I enjoy it for breakfast but for dinner a step above Chef Mickey but still less than average buffet food.
3. Cape May - Not even the skinny and anorexic crab legs saved this place from my list of bottom feeders at WDW.

As you can tell I'm not a big fan of buffets.

 

[3CW]

1. Le Cellier
2. Sanaa
3. Tutto Italia
4. Tiffins
5. Yak & Yeti
6. Kona
7. Hollywood Brown Derby
8. Jiko
9. Sci-Fi
10. Chefs de France
11. San Angel Inn
12. The Plaza
13. Skippers’ Canteen
14. Nine Dragons
    
15. Spirit of Aloha
16. Trattoria al Forno
17. Tony’s Town Square
18. Tokyo Dining
19. ‘Ohana
20. Cinderella’s Royal Table
21. Planet Hollywood
22. Yachtsman Steakhouse
23. Restaurant Marrakesh
24. House of Blues
25. Biergarten

Top 3 worst, just for fun:
1. The Wave
2. Maya Grill
3. Crystal Palace

 

[kbmartin]

If I do this again, it would be interesting to allow people to vote for their 3 worst restaurants as well. 5, 3 and 1 points would be subtracted from those restaurant's overall score.

I'd have the 1. Plaza, 2. Captain's Grille and 3.Tony's Town Square.

Oh well, may be next time!

Perhaps that could be your next survey!

 

[SaraSpringsIsHome]

1. Todd English's bluezoo
2. Biergarten
3. Mama Melrose Restaurante
4. 50's Prime Time Cafe
5. Ohana
6. Kona Cafe
7. Raglan Road
8. Via Napoli
9. Chefs de France
10. Be Our Guest
11. Artist Point
12. Beaches and Cream
13. Jiko
14. Boma
15. Hoop de Doo
16. Restaurant Marrakesh
17. Bongos Cuban Cafe
18. Captain's Grille
19. Trails End
20. San Angel Inn
21. Garden Grill
22. Coral Reef
23. Chef Mickey's
24. Tony's Town Square
25. Cinderella's Royal Table

 

[shaycamp21]

1. Narcoosee's
2. Flying Fish
3. California Grill
4. Le Cellier
5. Wolfgang Puck's Cafe
6. Yak and Yeti
7. Boma
8. 1900 Park Fare
9. Crystal Palace
10. Kona Cafe
11. Olivia's
12. Via Napoli
13. Ohana
14. Akershus
13. Cape May
15. Hollywood and Vine
16. Chef Mickey's
17. Cinderella's Royal Table
18. Whispering Canyon Cafe
19. Grand Floridian Cafe
20. Mama Melrose
21. Tusker House
22. Sci Fi
23. Bongo's
24. Coral Reef
25. Chef's De France

 

[Raeven]

Top 25

1. Shulas Steak House
2. Chef Art Smith's Homecomin'
3. Jiko
4. California Grill (Brunch)
5. Boma (Breakfast)
6. The Hollywood Brown Derby
7. Tusker House (Breakfast)
8. Sci-Fi Dine-In Theater
9. Ohana (Breakfast)
10. Kona Cafe (Breakfast)
11. Sanaa
12. Hoop-Dee-Doo Musical Revue
13. Crystal Palace (Breakfast)
14. The Plaza
15. Yak and Yeti
16. Be Our Guest (Dinner)
17. Tiffins
18. Beaches and Cream
19. San Angel Inn
20. Captain's Grille (Breakfast)
21. Las Ventanas (Breakfast)
22. Ohana (Dinner)
23. T-REX
24. 1900 Park Fare (Dinner)
25. Trail's End Restaurant (Dinner)

Worst 3

1. Las Ventanas (Lunch)
2.Be Our Guest (Lunch)
3.Trail's End Restaurant (Dinner)
(This was definitely one of the worst, but I needed another to make 25

 

[Planogirl]

1. Boma
2. Via Napoli
3. Rose & Crown
4. Kona Cafe
5. Splitsville
6. Trails End
7. Sci-Fi
8. Chefs de France
9. Captains Grille
10. 'Ohana
11. Cape May
12. Nine Dragons
13. Crystal Palace
14. House of Blues
15. Beaches and Cream

We've been to others but I can't think of any that I want to list.

 

[Willlyb]

We've only done 22:

1.Beaches and Cream
2.Via Napoli
3.Be Our Guest Restaurant Dinner
4.1900 Park Fare
5.Akershus Royal Banquet Hall
6.Tusker House
7.Biergarten
8.Ohana
9.The Plaza
10.Cinderella's Royal Table
11.Liberty Tree Tavern
12.50's Prime Time Cafe
13.Hollywood and Vine
14.Crystal Palace
15.Mickey's Backyard BBQ
16.Chef Mickey's
17.Rainforest Cafe at Downtown Disney
18.Tony's Town Square
19.Boatwright's Dining Hall
20.Garden Grove
21.Planet Hollywood
22.Sci-Fi Dine-In Theater

 

[DrunkJam]

1) Tusker House Breakfast
2) Ohana
3) Narcoosees
4) Le Cellier
5) The Wave Dinner
6) Crystal Palace Breakfast
7) Artist's Pointe
8) Kona Breakfast
8) Sci Fi
9) 1900 Park Fare Breakfast

And worst...
1) Boma (why must everything taste sweet and of cinnamon?)
2) Chef Mickey's Breakfast
3) Akershus - although my DH requested to do this twice more.

 

[nco91590]

1. California Grill
2. Yachtsman
3. Le Cellier
4. The Wave
5. Homecoming
6. Narcoossees
7. Raglan Road
8. Captain's Grille
9. Rose and Crown
10. Chefs de France
11. Biergarten
12. Tutto Italia


From here they all become the same in mediocrity.

 

[Yahweh]

Update Results #1

Rank-(Score) Restaurant -Total Points (#of times a Top 5 ranking)

1. (12.35) Kona Cafe- 284 Points (4)
2. (10.43) California Grill- 240 Points (9)
3. (9.70) Tusker House- 223 Points (5)
4. (9.48) Be Our Guest Dinner- 218 Points (4)
5. (9.43) Boma- 217 Points (6)
6. (8.87) Ohana- 204 Points (3)
7. (7.95) Chefs de France- 183 Points (0)
8. (7.83) The Wave- 180 Points (6)
9. (7.52) Sci-Fi Dine-In Theater- 173 Points (1)
10. (7.43) 1900 Park Faire- 171 Points (2)
11. (7.22) Via Napoli- 166 Points (4)
12. (7.09) Jiko- 163 Points (5)
13. (7.04) Crystal Palace- 162 Points (0)
14. (6.78) Raglan Road- 156 Points (3)
15. (6.70) Cinderella's Royal Table- 154 Points (3)
16. (6.17) Rose & Crown- 142 Points (3)
17. (5.91) Le Cellier Steakhouse- 136 Points (4)
18. (5.83) Narcoossee’s- 134 Points (4)
19. (5.56) Flying Fish- 128 Points (4)
20. (5.08) The Hollywood Brown Derby- 117 Points (1)
21. (5.04) San Angel Inn- 116 Points (0)
22. (4.87) Yak & Yeti- 112 Points (1)
23. (4.83) Tokyo Dining- 111 Points (1)
24. (4.52) 50s Prime Time- 104 Points (1)
25. (4.09) Cape May Cafe- 94 Points (0)
26. (3.96) Biergarten- 91 Points (2)
27. (3.92) Captain’s Grill-90 Points (1)
28. (3.88) Homecomin’- 89 Points (4)
29. (3.82) Beaches and Cream- 88 Points (1)
30. (3.61) Sanaa- 83 Points (1)
31. (3.56) Victoria & Albert’s- 82 Points (2)
32. (3.52) Todd English's Bluezoo- 81 Points (3)
33. (3.39) Mama Melrose’s- 78 Points (1)
34. (3.39) Tiffins- 78 Points (2)
35. (3.30) Akershus- 76 Points (1)
36. (3.26) Skipper Canteen- 75 Points (1)
37. (3.09) Chef Mickey’s- 71 Points (0)
38. (3.09) Teppan Edo- 71 Points (2)
39. (3.05) Liberty Tree Tavern- 70 Points (1)
40. (2.96) Shula's Steak House- 68 Points (2)
41. (2.61) Tutto Italia- 60 Points (1)
42. (2.43) Rainforest Cafe- 56 Points (0)
43. (2.43) Hoop Dee Doo Revue- 56 Points (1)
44. (2.43) Artist Point- 56 Points (1)
45. (2.21) The Plaza- 51 Points (0)
46. (2.17) Monsieur Paul- 50 Points (1)
47. (1.96) Marrakesh- 45 Points (0)
48. (1.96) Trail's End- 45 Points (0)
49. (1.96) Boatwright’s- 45 Points (2)
50. (1.91) Yachtsman Steakhouse- 44 Points (1)
51. (1.82) Morimoto Asia- 42 Points (1)
52. (1.82) Hollywood and Vine- 42 Points (0)
53. (1.74) Whispering Canyon Cafe- 40 Points (0)
54. (1.52) Kimonos- 35 points (1)
55. (1.48) Citricos- 34 Points (0)
56. (1.30) Coral Reef- 30 Points (0)
57. (1.17) Splitsville- 27 Points (1)
58. (1.17) Olivia’s- 27 Points (0)
59. (1.13) Nine Dragons- 26 Points (0)
60. (1.09) Turf Club- 25 Points (1)
61. (1.04) Tony’s Town Square- 24 Points (0)
62. (1.00) Grand Floridian Cafe- 23 Points (0)
63. (1.00) Portobellos- 23 Points (1)
64. (0.91) Wolfgang Puck's Cafe- 21 Points (1)
65. (0.83) Spice Road Table- 19 Points (0)
66. (0.83) Fountain- 19 Points (0)
67. (0.70) Big River Grill- 16 Points (0)
68. (0.70) Coral Reef- 16 Points (0)
69. (0.61) Paradiso 37- 14 Points (0)
70. (0.61) Planet Hollywood- 14 Points (0)
71. (0.61) House of Blues- 14 Points (0)
72. (0.52) Trattoria al Forno- 12 Points (0)
73. (0.52) Bongos Cuban Cafe 12 Points (0)
    
74. (0.48) Mickey’s Backyard BBQ- 11 Points (0)
75. (0.48) Spirit of Aloha- 11 Points (0)
76. (0.43) La Hacienda de San Angel- 10 Points (0)
77. (0.30) Boatwright’s Dining Hall- 7 Points (0)
78. (0.26) Garden Grill- 6 Points (0)
79. (0.26) Garden Grove- 6 Points (0)
80. (0.22) Las Ventanas- 5 Points (0)
81. (0.17) T-Rex-4 Points (0)

 

[marcyleecorgan]

1) Crystal Palace
2) Nine Dragons
3) Hollywood & Vine
4) Garden Grill
5) Tokyo Dining
6 ) Chef Mickey's

I haven't eaten at the other TS yet, so there's my opinion...

 

[GillianP1301]

This was tough! I could easily group into 4 buckets, excellent, very good, good and terrible, but numbering within each group got a bit tough. I went past 25 just for fun to rank all the TS I've tried.

1) Yachtsman Steakhouse
2) Garden Grill
3) Chefs de France
4) California Grill
5) Ohana
6) Sci-Fi Dine-In Theater
7) Boma
8) Beaches and Cream
9) Yak and Yeti
10) Coral Reef
11) Skipper Canteen
12) Le Cellier Steakhouse
13) Rose and Crown
14) Tiffins
15) Biergarten
16) Crystal Palace
17) Cinderella's Royal Table
18) 50's Prime Time Cafe
19) 1900 Park Fare
20) Whispering Canyon Cafe
21) Kona Cafe
22) Tusker House
23) Hoop-Dee-Doo Musical Revue
24) The Plaza
25) Mama Melrose's Ristorante

26) Tony's Town Square
27) T-REX
28) Liberty Tree Tavern
29) Rainforest Cafe at Animal Kingdom
30) Be Our Guest Restaurant Diner
31) Chef Mickey's
32) Hollywood and Vine
33) Mickey's Backyard BBQ
34) Via Napoli

 

[LVSWL]

Favorite Restaurants

Narcoossee's
Artist Point
Wave
Chefs de France
Citricos
Blue Zoo
Flying Fish
Kona
Jiko
Hollywood Brown Derby
Yak & Yeti
Mama Melrose
La Hacienda

 

[Tonyz]

1. Sanaa – Food, service, price, ambiance, theme, consistency… it’s perfection.
2. Jiko – What else needs to be said? I only rank Sanaa higher because I’ve been there more.
3. Narcoossee's
4. Kona Café
5. O’hana

6. Boma
7. Cape May Café – Crab legs and clams. I’m in heaven.
8. Flying Fish – Only had the pork belly here but it was phenomenal.
9. Skipper Canteen
10. Le Cellier Steakhouse – Went once years ago before it was a signature and was among the best meals I’ve ever had. A lot has changed (and my roast chicken isn’t on the menu anymore… so sad) so who knows if it would hold up.

11. The Wave
12. Grand Floridian Cafe
13. Whispering Canyon Café
14. 50's Prime Time Café
15. Captain's Grille

 

[Nebraska_Disney]

1) The Wave (dinner)
2) Ohana (dinner)
3) Tepan Edo
4) Tusker House (brunch/breakfast)
5) Whispering Canyons (dinner)
6) Cape May (dinner)
7) Be our Guest (dinner)
8) Garden Grill
9) Olivia's
10) Ohana (breakfast)
11) Coral Reef
12) Liberty Tree (dinner)
13) Mamma Mesroses
14) Chef Mickey (dinner)
15) 1900 Park
16) Royal Table
17) Tony's
18) San Angel Inn
19) Biergarten

 

[Minnesota!]

• Boma
  
• Nine Dragons
  
• Splitsville
  
• Biergarten
  
• Sanaa
  
• Cape May
  
• Trails End
  
• Sci Fi
  
• Grand Floridian
  
• Kona
  
• Rose and Crown
  
• San Angel Inn
  
• Via Napoli
  
• Whispering Canyon

 

[Zachary Friess]

1. Via Napoli
2. Sci-Fi
3. Beaches and Cream
5. BOG Dinner
6. San Angel Inn
7. Yak and Yeti
8. Ale and Compass
9. Garden Grill Breakfast
10. Garden Grill Dinner
11. Cape May Breakfast
12. Cinderellas Royal Table
13. Whispering Canyon
14. Liberty Tree
15. Sanaa
16. Tusker House Breakfast
17. Ohana
18. Askerhus
19. Chefs De France
20. Crystal Palace Dinner
21. Hollywood and Vine
22. Mickeys backyard BBQ
23. 50s Prime Time
24. Hollywood and Vine
25. Nine Dragons