Tutto Italia: went once at lunch (walk up, no one in the place but us and another table), and the service was half-hearted while the food was just ok. It wasn't horrible, but it was so 'meh' that I have no desire to ever go back.
Garden Grill: I was so excited for our breakfast here, but the food wasn't great at all. The eggs were dry (both the first serving and our second helping), the meat was kind of odd tasting, and the tater tots were tater tots like I could heat up at home (and not too warm when they got to us). The only thing I really enjoyed during breakfast was the pull apart sweet rolls. However, I could do ok food if character interaction was good, but the characters were really low key...added to a seating arrangement that made it *really really really* difficult for the people in our party to get out from our booth to actually take pictures with the characters. Not a fan of it all, and left just really disappointed. I don't know if we'll be back, even for dinner.
Tusker House: I found the food just ok (dinner) and thought the place a bit big and chaotic. I might go back at some point, but I was underwhelmed.
Coral Reef: Like Tusker House, I was underwhelmed. The food was ok, and unless you're seated right next to the aquarium, the atmosphere is very meh to me. I might go back, but there are many other places higher on my list.
The take out pizza place on the Boardwalk is just not good...even my kids said it was bad pizza. When we stayed there last December, I walked over to the Fountain at the Swolfin rather than eat there as some in my party did. Sadly, our meal at the Fountain was almost just as bad, topped with really indifferent service. There are other places in that area that I love, so I'm not put off of eating in the general vicinity. I just won't get pizza or go to the Fountain again.