It would hardly be a blip on my radar.
A dorm full of people. Those sound like minor infractions.
Just walked in the door from orientation with ds#3 at his school 5 hours away. For the experience, we were able to stay in his dorm building . 6 floors with 2 people per room and 50 plus students per floor. There's no way to monitor 'adult children' and the 'damages' in the op sound very typical of a busy college dormitory.
There are always 'hidden' fees for activities, capital improvements, etc. tacked on to the front end of the bill anyway, why not the back end, too.
Ds#2 attends the same college and had a $3 charge at the end of his first year for a broken test tube in biology. He said it was in his equipment drawer in the classroom and rolled around and broke. I was a little surprised-figured they'd buy them in bulk and that it was already part of the course fee, but I guess it's got to be paid for somehow.