Skier_Pete...How am I not losing out? I'm not getting the free dining with my POR Royal room. My kids first Disney trip (DD 9, DS 8) and I thought the rooms decor felt more Disney.
Sorry, are you indicating that they confirmed you can't book that room with Free Dining? I got the impression that your TA hadn't confirmed that yet. Some level rooms they don't open up for free dining. In that case, you could lose out on free dining.
However, it is still your choice. You can choose that the Royal Room is more important than the free dining savings.
As I related elsewhere, in November 2011 we had planned a trip back to POFQ, which we hadn't stayed at in three years. DD was very excited to get back to the dragon slide pool. When free dining came out, POFQ wasn't eligble. We switched to CBR, because I couldn't justify paying $1200 more dollars to stay at POFQ (we also had my mom with us, for there were 4 of us for the
DDP). In the end, DD absolutely LOVED CBR, and this year she requested going back there.
My point is, while your kids may really like the Royal Room, it is unlikely that it would be the make-or-break to a great vacation. If it's that important to you, stick with it and pay the extra money, if not, take the savings and spend it on some great experiences. (One of the things DD loved about CBR was the Pirate Cruise, and it was only $30 and gave us a 2 hour break. Or do one of the tours -
http://www.wdwinfo.com/wdwinfo/tours.htm - We did the family magic tour a couple times back and DD loved this as well.) Not every discount works out for everyone, you often have to be flexible to take advantage of them.
SP