I thought about that! We would like the food there as well. I was wondering how it worked out for anyone who dined there during the fireworks.We loved the food and the service at Rose and Crown! We were too wiped to stay for Illuminations, but we'd have had a great view.
Everyones tastes differ, as you have already seen by the replies. I don't believe there is a single favorite restaurant.
If you want a Rose & Crown table near Illuminations time, try for an ADR around 7:30 - 7:45. You can only request a patio table at check in (everyone does) and it is the luck of the draw if your request can be met. If you are seated inside, there is a private, standing room only, patio for patrons of Rose & Crown to view Illuminations. There is no guarantee of a patio table.
Check out the menus here on the DIS and at allears.net and see what appeals to you and your family.
I have been looking into Rose & Crown specifically to find a good viewing spot for the illuminations. I have ate at the quick service next to it and liked the food and love the Stout! Do you know a rough percentage of how many tables are on the patio compared to inside? I mean, if there is a hundred tables inside and only 10 out, then you know what your chances are going to be. Also, this private standing room only patio for patrons, what is that like? I am sure it is packed but it is separate from the dining patio? I am sure it is packed, wondering if my seven year old will be able to see anything if she is squished between adults. Thanks so much for your reply! This really helps with the planning.