DW and I had always avoided it thinking that it was just Disney Olive Garden, but due to a lack of options we went on our last trip in March 2020. Neither of us would tell you that it was amazing but it was pleasantly surprising. We aren't personally fans of Brown Derby, tried it once and just eh, especially given that we usually use the dining plan and don't consider it worth two credits. After our experience if we want a table service meal in HS, which is generally very weak on dining options, we'd probably go back to Mama Melrose.