Ok, first off - the Cantina holds 200-250 people at once. So even "holding" 12 spaces over the course of a day where all patrons are limited to 45 minutes in the restaurant barely even registers in terms of availability.
If there was really an issue with "ADR hoarding" as you call it, then WDW would put limitations on the number of ADRs an individual can make at a given establishment. The poster you are calling into question is playing well within the rules that WDW has established for booking dining. That's really all that matters - not whether or not you feel it's right.
Many people have had success using TP's reservation finder. Plus others reported that there appeared to be more availability released today. It's possibly WDW is releasing them slowly into the system.
Not exactly sure why you're only quoting my post when the majority of the other posts on this thread are addressing the same thing and showing how the majority on the thread feel about ADR hoarding. ???? And BTW, "ADR hoarding" was not coined by me but used over the years on here to describe exactly what is discussed here.... holding on to many reservations without the intent to use them all. When I booked my Oga's, (this morning) I booked a reservation for two for one time slot. I didn't look for more or try to get as many as I could. And yes, like it or not it does affect other people's vacations when ADR's are hoarded.
And Disney gets paid if someone doesn't make their reservation time, so they really don't care about others not getting an ADR at all. So no, they are not going to put limitations on the current system. They only do it when it gets really bad like BOG, but still make a ton of money. ($28 for eggs and toast? Come on!) My opinion is that they should treat it like a dessert party and actually charge your credit card for an amount, even a small amount and then apply that amount to your bill when you actually arrive and order. If they cancel, then they get the money refunded, just like a dessert party. That would curb some of the ADR hoarding and level the playing field a little.
You may have missed some information in my posts, so I'll point it out again.....
...........
I know people are hording ADR's for Oga's and I'm not debating the right-or-wrong of it. I'm stating it for others to understand WHY they may not get into the land at all, let alone Oga's. And I can totally understand why it's not a popular post for those of us who can't even get ONE ADR. But, Disney creates these monsters with their system and I will be going to Disney again so I don't get too bent about these situations. But I also don't hoard ADR's because I have personal opinion against it.
And my response pointing out the poster's signature line and thread was in direct response to the poster stating that she
didn't mention anywhere when she was going and that her reservations wouldn't help most who a problem with her ADR methods, which I was one person going at the same time and those 12 spots were 12 less shots that I personally had. I saw others post they were going the same time too, so they had a few less chances as well. The more people hoarding, the less chance for others...that's just a fact. Thankfully once people started realizing that Oga's is actually a bar and not a restaurant, they started to dump them.
This (below) perfectly sums up WHY people get upset with what they see as hoarding, bragging and the response that some people will get "pixie dust" down the road when plans are finalized.
.........
I truly hope you all that didn't get one, can manage. No one should hope for pixie dust, just a fair shot.
Again, Disney created this monster and not every does get a fair shot.
Ehhhh no. People rushed to book 'the hot new thing' and didn't realize they were booking a bar spot instead of a restaurant and are dumping their ADR's in droves. That has been reported pretty much everywhere.
It's probably not so much the ADR hoarding, as the need to humble brag about it on a forum on a day that people couldn't even access the site that rubbed some the wrong way. No amount of justification will make that easier to swallow.
Exactly..... I posted earlier in the thread that Disney is trying to use their existing ADR system to book a time slot for people to get into the bar.