so here are my thought on how things are for us.. Maybe good to share for anyone going back and forth on the issue
Basics.
4 disney "adults" 31Aug-07Sep
currently have an awesome TA special.
@3500.00 for BC RO with PH and one day Water Park "Extra"
Past 5 years we did FD at PoR.. last year we did a split FD at PoR and then 3 days RO at BC... so that got our heads in the direction of BC.. Especially this year due to F&W which we have never done, and also for my mom location wise nice as there is plenty to do outside the Resort that is a short walking distance for her to do on her own.. Boardwalk and Epcot.. We all love PoR but we are leaning more BC ( when the price is right and it is in this case).
So we booked again this TA special but no dining.. Each year with free dining we used our TS for the staples: Boma, Tusker, Chef Mickey, 2 for Hoop dee doo. etc... TS we spent on buffets,, meaning OOP at least 200 plus a huge tip amount on that level. even with FD our tips for that week were in the 200 or so dollars.
I am still waiting to see what FD is this year and if/when it comes do the math just to see.. right now I have above booked. No way we can afford rack for BC and get FD.. So if we do FD, then it's back to PoR...In a way a bummer as in our heads, we have the Epcot area, BC and SAB on our minds. Maybe a split again .who knows.. need to do the math.
Assuming PoR has room (our dates are usually the best for availability here). I took a garden room minimum ( standard FD you can forget).
with FD we are at about 3900 ( PH plus we would have gotten anyways do we aren't forced )
That is for garden, if that is sold out price can go up 100-400 depending on room, which Royal being most expensive..So worse case let's guestmate 4200.. NOW and the big what if,,, if mods only get QS and we want then TS, I calculated i believe it was 23 person/day?? so add now @644 to 4200.. that is @4844 for the trip.
That is 1344 difference to my TA deal... the only benefit besides the food is that we have 8 extras for water park, with TA we only get one day, but we plan one day anyways only.
That is 192 per day for food.. Now if we went all out like with FD , we can easily spend that on buffetts per day. I had budgeted OOP about 120 for us per day.. breakfast in rooms, and only 2 or 3 TS per trip, rest QS we split as we really have 2 kids. We would buy only 2 resort mugs and share.
And we get a deluxe resort with a great pool.. In essence FD gives us a moderate with a few buffets more, or we do TA and get Deluxe resort..
In a way last year, we got buffett burn out,, year after year and the time spend on eating..so in way it's freeeing limiting ourselves...with F&W I plan to snack anyways.
Am I missing anything in my calculations??? I am 90% we are sticking with TA.. especially if new FD is QS only.