Hello Mary!
I can understand how hard it is to pick the perfect hotel! I know we threw around all of the different deluxe hotels for quite some time.
We stayed at the Polynesian Garden Concierge! It was very blissful! The grounds are beautiful, lush and tropical, you really feel like you are in Hawaii! The Concierge staff was great too, took care of all of our restaurant reservations and booked me a trip to the spa, ahhh it was great!!!
There are lots of great restaurants at the resort too, Ohana's where you can see the MK fireworks! Kona Cafe has scrumptious desserts and their legendary Tonga Toast!
The new pool is done too, with a Volcano water slide!
Overall it was a wonderful Honeymoon and I would stay there again in a heartbeat!!!
If you are looking into the Animal Kingdom Resort, consider splitting your stay with the Polynesian. For one you would have the beauty of the AK Resort and quiet time, and for the Polynesian you would have that peacefulness and also the convience of the monorail and the TTC for transportation!
Have a wonderful Honeymoon though, whatever you decide!!!