We've done the Caribbean and Bahamas on the Dream and the Fantasy and those were great, but our favorite was the Magic out of New York last year over Thanksgiving Week 2018. We sailed out of Manhattan and stopped in Castaway Cay and then Port Canaveral. On the PC day, everyone received park hopper tickets to WDW. We boarded buses as soon as we cleared Customs and they took us to whatever park we chose. Buses were available to return to the Magic throughout the day. We boarded one of last buses to leave the Magic Kindgom as the fireworks were happening. We got back to the Magic, grabbed a late snack from Cabanas and fell into our beds. It was a great day! The cruise was a Merrytime Cruise, so decorations and holiday activities were everywhere, 4 at sea days, a beautiful sail away past the NYC Skyline and the Statue of Liberty, a stop at Castaway Cay and a day at WDW. For us this was the perfect cruise. We were so disappointed when we found out that this itinerary isn't planned for Thanksgiving week in 2020 and 2021. We totally would have booked this cruise for those years. Fingers crossed for this one reappearing on the schedule for Thanksgiving 2021.