Runners World
tweeted out this article last week that might help you decide if a coach is right for you.
For ME - and, again, this is one of those things that is a purely person-to-person kind of thing - until I decided to run Dopey, I basically relied on traditional running plans to help stretch me out so I could accomplish the distance (at the time, a half marathon distance) upright and injury-free, without a true time goal, but mostly in a reduced timeframe for training (I ran my first half marathon less than six weeks after my first-ever 10k). I also relied on good friends who were runners, and were running the same race as me, for advice and things like that. And it worked really well for a while.
When I decided to attempt Dopey, I relied pretty heavily on
@FFigawi (which - it's all his fault that he got me into the whole Dopey situation, so he might as well help me get out of it!). So, for my training, he acted as my de facto coach/mentor - he critiqued my training plan, offered advice when I needed it, talked me off the ledge probably more than he ever planned on (Yeah, I'm THAT person), and really gave me the advice that nobody else could give me - what Dopey would ACTUALLY be like. How I needed to train and approach everything, the mindset and training I needed going into race weekend. All of that good stuff. We never really did anything in-depth like breaking down my training runs and times, things like that, but he knew that time wasn't my goal - FINISHING was.
I did attempt to find someone locally that could help me, both in the running club I run local races through AND through two running stores that I make all my purchases from, but nobody had even attempted a Challenge at Disney, and the small number of people that had run a Disney race had run the Marathon years ago. So, finding someone local wouldn't work. I even reached out to the person who organizes the NYC/Marine Corps Marathon training group here in my city to see if they could help me approach Dopey and that was a total no-go. In fact, that person had serious questions about why a person would even want to attempt a challenge like that. So, that was the end of that search for me. Again, it just happens. ~8k people run Dopey every year, and it's only been going for three years - so the sample size for finding a coach that had experienced the Challenge itself was already going to be small.
When I finished Dopey, I had to kind of assess what my goals were going forward. And I think that, going forward, my ultimate goal is to become a better (which does not necessarily mean faster) runner, and to transition from training specifically for a race or a race season into conditioning more on a weekly basis so that at any point in time, I can schedule out a couple of long runs and be ready to run a destination race and have fun. I would like to also be better prepared to run a standalone marathon, and maybe shave some time off my half marathon time. But really, that's it. I have no intention of things like BQing (nor would I EVER be able to, just based on my level of fitness and some serious lifestyle choices I would have to make to get serious about it).